Thursday, May 27, 2010

05272010 - Sam Riddle - Sentenced - DV Assault Against State Rep Mary Waters




Also See:


Sam Riddle's arrest and trial for domestic violence assault on former Michigan State Representative Mary Waters [December 21, 2009]:



















Riddle Loses Appeal Over Assault, Gun Convictions
Updated: Wednesday, 23 Nov 2011, 11:01 AM EST
Published : Wednesday, 23 Nov 2011, 11:01 AM EST
FOX TV News, Detroit
http://www.myfoxdetroit.com/dpp/news/local/riddle-loses-appeal-over-assault-gun-convictions-20111123




Sam Riddle appears in court for sentencing on May 27, 2010. (Credit: myFOXDetroit.com)


DETROIT - The Michigan appeals court has upheld the convictions of Sam Riddle, a Detroit political consultant who pulled out a shotgun when his companion found him in bed with another woman.

The appeals court said Wednesday that a rational person encountering Riddle would have believed his conduct was hostile.

Riddle was convicted of felonious assault and a gun crime last year. His companion at the time, Mary Waters, called police after discovering him in bed with another woman. Riddle pulled out a shotgun and racked it, although Waters testified that she didn't believe the gun was loaded.

The appeals court says a lack of fear doesn't erase an assault. Riddle's two-year prison sentence is being served at the same time as his 37-month federal sentence for corruption.










SAM RIDDLE GETS SENTENCED TO 2 YEARS IN PRSION FOR ASSAULT CASE
05.28.2010 07.15 am
Detroit Online
http://www.idetroitonline.com/archive/news/05-28-2010-sam-riddle-gets-2-years.html





DETROIT POLITICAL CONSULTANT....
Sam Riddle has been sentenced to two years in prison in an assault case involving a shotgun and his companion.

Riddle got his punishment Thursday in Wayne County Circuit Court. He had been found guilty of pulling out a shotgun when his live-in companion, Mary Waters, found him in bed with another woman in December.

Judge Gregory Bill ordered two years in prison for the gun crime and probation for the assault.

Riddle is in federal custody and hopes to stay there to serve his state sentence. He surrendered to U.S. marshals Tuesday to get a head start on a sentence for corruption.

Riddle pleaded guilty to conspiracy last week and faces up to 37 months in prison when he gets his sentence in August.

Although Wayne County Circuit Judge Gregory Bill remanded the controversial political consultant to the custody of the Wayne County Sheriff and the Michigan Department of Corrections, just where Riddle will serve his time remains undecided.

"It is our hope that he will go into the federal system," said Richard Convertino, Riddle's lawyer in federal court, where he faces sentencing for corruption charges for which he pleaded guilty last week.

Sentencing in that case is set for August, but Riddle, 63, turned himself in on Tuesday to U.S. Marshalls. Riddle was returned today to the custody of federal authorities who have kept him in the St. Clair County Jail. The arrangement caused confusion and the postponement of Riddle's planned sentencing on the assault and gun charge in Wayne County on Wednesday.

Today, Bill gave Riddle the mandatory sentence for using a firearm in the commission of a felony crime. Riddle also was given three years probation for assault. Riddle's conviction on the charges stemmed from an incident before Christmas in which Waters found Riddle in her bed with another woman.

Bill eased the way for federal authorities to take Riddle by ruling that the gun charge can be served concurrently with any sentence he receives in federal court in his corruption plea. Under state law, the two-year gun violation sentence must be served before any other sentences given under state statute. Wayne County Assistant Prosecutor Rebecca Camargo also said her office has no objection to Bill's ruling or to Riddle serving his time in federal custody.

During his sentencing, Riddle told the judge that he takes full responsibility for his actions, "the shame and the blame for it." He said he has tried to do good things in his life, and he plans to return to Detroit after he is released from prison.

"I will fight for a better Detroit. I will champion peace over violence," said Riddle who has developed a large following for his bold comments on Internet social networking websites such as Facebook and Twitter. "I could have railed against the system being up against a brother, but I'm not."

Waters, who is Riddle's co-defendant in one of his federal cases, and Riddle's minister, the Rev. Horace Sheffield, also made statements in court about the good Riddle has done in Detroit.

"I do sit here today as a victim, but not of Sam Riddle, but of the system," said Waters who added that she never wanted Riddle charged with a crime. "When I made that 911 call that day, I did it for Sam. We both were under a great deal of pressure. ... Oh, I was mad, but I wanted to get counseling for Sam, for his drinking."

Waters asked the judge to consider any "loophole" that might allow Riddle to remain free. But Sheffield said he understood the judge was bound by the law to give Riddle the two-year mandatory sentenced.

"I want Sam to be encouraged. That's why I am here," said Sheffield, who also said he was Riddle's Alcoholic's Anonymous sponsor. "I know he struggled with alcohol. The chemical has more power over you then your will."

Last week, Riddle pleaded guilty in front of U.S. District Judge Marianne O. Battani to a federal conspiracy charge that will send him to prison for up to 37 months. As part of his plea, Riddle admitted bribing former Southfield City Councilman William Lattimore in connection with a pawn shop relocation, extorting businesses when he worked as a top aide to former Detroit City Councilwoman Monica Conyers, and evading federal taxes on his ill-gotten gains.

When his first federal trial on Detroit corruption charges ended with a hung jury, Riddle said he had planned to continue to fight. But he changed his mind after his conviction in the assault case.

Waters, whom Riddle had been ordered to stay away from while the domestic assault issue was pending, said after the sentencing today that she will be taking over Riddle's popular Facebook pages on which he has more than 8,000 followers.

"I will be trying to keep Sam's many friends up to date on where he is and what's going on," Waters said.










Sam Riddle sentenced to 2 years in prison for gun conviction; 3 years probation for assault
Posted: 05/27/2010
By: Michael Rosenfield
WXYZ TV News, Detroit
http://www.wxyz.com/dpp/news/region/wayne_county/sam-riddle-sentenced-to-2-years-in-prison-for-gun-conviction%3B-3-years-for-assault











Sam Riddle Addresses the Court at his sentencing hearing.




Former State Representative Mary Waters testifies at Sam Riddle's sentencing hearing.




Former State Representative Mary Waters testifies at Sam Riddle's sentencing hearing.



Sam Riddle




Sam Riddle




Former State Representative Mary Waters breaks down during her testimony during Sam Riddle's sentencing hearing.




Sam Riddle is taken into custody after his sentencing hearing.




Sam Riddle is taken into custody after his sentencing hearing.




Former State Representative Mary Waters informs the media, after the sentencing hearing, that she still considers Sam Riddle her friend.



DETROIT, Mich. (WXYZ) - Political consultant Sam Riddle was sentenced Thursday to the mandatory 2 years for a firearms conviction. He also received 3 years probation for assault.

A Wayne County jury convicted Riddle three weeks ago of assaulting long-time companion and former state representative Mary Waters and pointing a shotgun at her after she walked in on him in bed with another woman in December.

Riddle told the judge he takes full responsibility for his actions.

Waters was also allowed to address the court. She said she was never a battered woman. Rather, she says she was a victim of the Wayne County Prosecutor because she never wanted felony charges filed. She says she only called 911 the day of the crime to get Riddle help for his drinking.

Riddle will serve the time concurrently with the sentence he will receive in August in connection with a federal bribary and corruption case. He faces up to 37 months after reaching a plea deal with federal prosecutors.

Riddle turned himself in to federal authorities earlier this week to ensure he would serve his prison time in a federal prison rather than a state prison because he was in their custody first.

Riddle today could have received up to 17 months behind bars on the assault charge.




Monday, May 3, 2010

05032010 - Deputy Scott Ford - Violation Of Probation - Emmet County SD

FORMER DEPUTY SCOTT FORD: VIOLATION OF PROBATION [ MAY 03, 2010 ].

On January 12, 2010, Ford was sentenced to 11 months in jail and two years of probation. On May 03, 2010, Ford violated the terms of his probation.

"According to reports written May 3 by two separate corrections officers at the Charlevoix County Jail, Ford was “allegedly exposing himself in a sexual manner toward female inmates.”







ALSO SEE:
DEPUTY SCOTT FORD, EMMET COUNTY SD [October 19, 2007]
Misuse of Sheriff Department LEIN system to stalk ex-girlfriend.
http://michiganoidv.blogspot.com/2009/03/deputy-scott-ford-emmet-county-sd.html

DEPUTY SCOTT FORD, EMMET COUNTY SD [Summer 2008]
Sexually assaulted a woman during traffic stops

http://michiganoidv.blogspot.com/2008/06/deputy-scott-ford-emmet-county-sd.html

DEPUTY SCOTT FORD, EMMET COUNTY SD [December 07, 2008]
Misconduct while on duty.

http://michiganoidv.blogspot.com/2008/12/deputy-scott-ford-emmet-county-sd.html
Michigan Officer Involved Domestic Violence





ORIGINAL CHARGES:  Two counts of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct, three counts of obstructing justice, five felony weapon charges for committing crimes in uniform while armed with his service pistol; two counts of refusing to aid the sheriff; false certification impermissible use of personal information, unauthorized access of the LEIN computer network; and two counts of using a computer to commit a crime.













Ford sentenced to additional month in jail and sex offender assessment for probation violation
July 02, 2010
By Christina Rohn News-Review Staff Writer

Petoskey News
http://articles.petoskeynews.com/2010-07-02/scott-harold-ford_24152101

A former Emmet County Sheriff’s deputy, who recently admitted to violating his two-year probation term while serving time in the Charlevoix County Jail, had an additional month added to his sentence Thursday, July 1, in 57th Circuit Court.

Scott Harold Ford, 40, of Carp Lake was more than halfway complete with serving the first six months of his 11-month jail term, which Judge Charles W. Johnson sentenced him to in January, for crimes he had pleaded guilty to committing in 2007 and 2008.

Ford was sentenced for one count of unauthorized access of a computer network (Law Enforcement Information Network), a five-year felony; and two counts of refusal to aid the sheriff, both of which are 90-day misdemeanors.

During the time of his initial sentencing, Johnson ordered Ford to serve the first six months of his punishment in the Charlevoix County Jail, with the possibility of tether if he exhibited good behavior. In addition, he was also allowed work release.

This changed on May 3, when two corrections officers from the Charlevoix County Jail reported that Ford had been “allegedly exposing himself in a sexual manner toward female inmates.”

A jail disciplinary board conducted a review of Ford’s actions and determined that he was responsible for unauthorized communication with other inmates, as well as creating a disturbance.

On June 3, Ford pleaded guilty to unauthorized communication, and as a result, the Emmet County Prosecutor’s Office dismissed the second count against him.

During Ford’s probation violation sentencing Thursday, July 1, Duane Beach, chief assistant prosecutor for Emmet County, asked that Johnson require Ford to complete a sex offender assessment.

“I’m urging this court to consider this deviant behavior,” Beach said. “It wasn’t like he chose a private place to do it ... it certainly merits an assessment to find the cause of this behavior.”

Toward the end of the proceedings, Ford wept as he spoke on his own behalf.

“Your honor, I’m not a sex offender ... I did involve myself in behavior that is ridiculous now that I think about it,” he said. “This is no place I ever saw myself ... I’m losing so much, my house is for sale ... I have no income, and I’ve never been without a job my entire adult life — I’m out of options with my wife ... I just want this to be over.”

Judge Johnson asked Ford why he wasn’t thinking of these things before he participated in the action that brought him before the court.

“It was a stupid game,” Ford said. “It was poor, poor judgment. I apologize to have to waste the court’s time.”

As a result of these proceedings, Johnson revoked Ford’s opportunity for work release or tether, and added an additional month to his 11-month sentence — making his a one-year jail term, with 173 days credit for time already served.


In addition, Johnson is also requiring that Ford receive a sex offender assessment.


“This defendant’s conduct is characterized as grossly inappropriate for many, many reasons, not the least of which is that this man is married,” Johnson said.








Ex-deputy Ford admits to probation violation
could face five years in prison
June 04, 2010
Christina Rohn

Petoskey News
http://articles.petoskeynews.com/2010-06-04/probation_24150981

A former sheriff's deputy pleaded guilty today in 57th Circuit Court to three of the nine charges against him.

Scott Harold Ford, 39, of Carp Lake, who was fired from the Emmet County Sheriff's Department in December of 2008, for allegedly committing several acts of misconduct while on duty, pleaded guilty Monday to one count of unauthorized access of a computer network (Law Enforcement Information Network), a five-year felony; and two counts of refusal to aid the sheriff, both 90-day misdemeanors.

In exchange for this plea, the Emmet County Prosecutor's Office dismissed the remaining six charges against Ford, which include one count of false certification - impermissible use of personal information, a five-year felony; one count of using a computer to commit a crime, a seven-year felony; two counts of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct, both two-year, high-court misdemeanors; and two counts of obstructing justice, both five-year felonies.

Judge Charles W. Johnson sentenced him to 11 months in jail, two years probation and 200 hours of community service.

The 39-year-old Carp Lake resident was being sentenced for three charges he pleaded guilty to in October 2009, which included one count of unauthorized access of a computer network (Law Enforcement Information Network), a five-year felony; and two counts of refusal to aid the sheriff, both of which are 90-day misdemeanors.

During sentencing, Johnson stipulated that Ford would be required to spend the first six months of his sentence in jail, with the opportunity for tether if he exhibits good behavior.


Former Emmet County Sheriff’s deputy Scott Ford pleaded guilty Thursday, June 3, in 57th Circuit Court to “unauthorized communication” with fellow inmates — one of two probation violation counts against him.

At the time of this alleged violation, Ford was serving time in the Charlevoix County Jail for a previous crime.

In January, Judge Charles W. Johnson ordered Ford to serve 11 months in jail, with the first six months to be served immediately, after he pleaded guilty in October 2009 to one count of unauthorized access of a computer network (the Law Enforcement Information Network) and two counts of refusal to aid the sheriff.

As part of Ford’s sentence, he was also placed on two years probation, and granted work release, as well as the opportunity for tether if he exhibited good behavior.

According to reports written May 3 by two separate corrections officers at the Charlevoix County Jail, Ford was “allegedly exposing himself in a sexual manner toward female inmates.”

 

During his plea hearing Thursday, Ford admitted his guilt to Judge Johnson for the first count against him.

“I was improperly communicating with other inmates,” he said. “I was making hand gestures and communication gestures though the reflection of a jail window.”

As a result of his plea, the Emmet County Prosecutor’s Office is dropping the second charge against Ford in his probation violation case.

Although a date has not yet been set for Ford’s sentencing on this matter, Judge Johnson indicated that he could face up to five years in prison for the charge.


In addition, Johnson stated during Thursday’s hearing that Ford would no longer be allowed work release, and that tether was out of the question.









Ex-Emmet County deputy Scott Ford to be sentenced July 1 for probation violation
June 16, 2010
Christina Rohn

Petoskey News
http://articles.petoskeynews.com/2010-06-16/scott-harold-ford_24151923

A former Emmet County Sheriff’s deputy, who recently violated his two-year probation while serving time in the Charlevoix County Jail, is set for sentencing next month.

Scott Harold Ford, 40, of Carp Lake, was more than halfway complete with serving a six-month jail sentence handed down in January by 57th Circuit Court Judge Charles W. Johnson for improper use of the Law Enforcement Information Network and refusing to aid the sheriff, when he violated his probation.

According to reports written May 3 by two separate corrections officers at the Charlevoix County Jail, Ford was “allegedly exposing himself in a sexual manner toward female inmates.”

As a result, a jail disciplinary board conducted a review of Ford’s actions, and determined that he was responsible for the allegations of unauthorized communication with other inmates, as well as creating a disturbance.

On Jan. 3, Ford pleaded guilty to unauthorized communication, and as a result of his plea, the Emmet County Prosecutor’s Office dismissed the second count against him.





Ford asks for hearing on probation violation
May 21, 2010
By Steve Zucker

Petoskey News
http://articles.petoskeynews.com/2010-05-21/probation_24150682

Former Emmet County Sheriff’s deputy Scott Ford, has asked a judge for a full hearing on charges that he violated his probation while serving time in the Charlevoix County Jail.

Ford, 39, stood mute when he was brought before 57th Circuit Court Judge Charles W. Johnson Thursday to answer charges that some of his alleged actions while incarcerated violated the terms of his probation.

Through his attorney, he requested that a full evidentiary hearing be scheduled for the judge to determine if he has violated the terms of his probation. The hearing will be scheduled in about 30 days.

In January, Ford was sentenced to serve 11 months in jail, with the first six months to be served immediately after he pleaded guilty in October to one count of unauthorized access of a computer network and two counts of refusing to aid the sheriff.

Ford served as an Emmet County sheriff’s deputy for nearly nine years, and admitted during a plea hearing in October to unlawfully accessing the Law Enforcement Information Network on Oct. 18, 2007, to access the personal information of an ex-girlfriend, who alleged that she and her children suffered psychological harm from his conduct

More recently, a disciplinary board at the Charlevoix County Jail found Ford responsible for allegations of “unauthorized communication with other inmates” and "creating a disturbance.”






Ford facing probation violation hearing
May 20, 2010
By Steve Zucker

Petoskey News
http://articles.petoskeynews.com/2010-05-20/probation_24152212

A former Emmet County Sheriff’s Deputy could see more time added to the jail sentence he is currently serving when he faces a probation violation hearing today, Thursday.

Scott Harold Ford, 39, of Carp Lake is scheduled to be back in 57th Circuit Court at 3:30 p.m. today, Thursday, to answer allegations that he has violated his probation by means of his behavior while incarcerated in the Charlevoix County Jail, Emmet County Prosecutor Jim Linderman said.

In January, Ford was sentenced to serve 11 months in jail, with the first six months to be served immediately after he pleaded guilty in October to one count of unauthorized access of a computer network and two counts of refusing to aid the sheriff.

Ford served as an Emmet County sheriff’s deputy for nearly nine years, and admitted during a plea hearing in October, to unlawfully accessing the Law Enforcement Information Network on Oct. 18, 2007, to access the personal information of an ex-girlfriend, who alleged that she and her children suffered psychological harm from his conduct.

Emmet County Sheriff Pete Wallin fired Ford within hours of learning of the allegations against him.

Linderman said the probation violation stems from allegations that Ford has engaged in disruptive and threatening behavior while at the Charlevoix County Jail. He said at this time, Ford is not facing any new charges in connection with his alleged behavior, but he said conditions of Ford’s probation prohibit such behavior.


According to officials at the Charlevoix County Jail, a jail disciplinary board found Ford responsible for allegations of “unauthorized communication with other inmates” and "creating a disturbance.”

Jail officials said Ford admitted to both counts.
According to jail officials, Ford was accused of violating jail rules by attempting to communicate with other inmates outside of his cell using various hand gestures and signs, and that his attempts to do this caused a disturbance among his cell-mates who were concerned that his actions could also get them in trouble.

Linderman said if Ford is found responsible for the probation violation, the judge could add to the sentence he has already imposed.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

04012010 - Judge Lynda Tolen - Sentenced - Berrien County [Retired]


Also See: Arrested for domestic violence
http://michiganoidv.blogspot.com/2011/12/judge-lynda-tolen-berrien-county-retired.html



Retired Berrien County Judge Lynda Tolen: Sentenced to 20 days in jail for second drunk driving offense, while on probation.



2010: Arrested and charged for drunk driving. Placed on probation.

2010: Arrested for a second drunk driving charge while on probation for first DUI. Setenced to 20 days in jail.

November 30, 2010: State of Michigan suspended Tolen's license to practice law for 180 days [due to her DUI convictions].

December 22, 2011: Arrested for domestic violence.









Former judge in front of bench again
Lynda Tolen arraigned on domestic violence charge
Posted: Friday, December 30, 2011 12:00 am
Herald Palladium
http://www.heraldpalladium.com/localnews/former-judge-in-front-of-bench-again/article_4aa0a047-5eb1-5bac-b81c-aa597392e046.html

ST. JOSEPH - Retired Berrien County Trial Court Judge Lynda Tolen, who has faced drunk driving charges in the past, was back in court this week on charges of domestic violence.

Tolen, 60, of Stevensville, who retired in 2008 after 21 years as a judge, was arraigned Tuesday on the misdemeanor charge, according to a report from WNDU-TV.

The complaint, which Chief Assistant Prosecutor Michael Sepic showed to The Herald-Palladium, stated that Tolen had assaulted a woman named Lisa Brasseur.

The complaint lists Brasseur as a resident or former resident of the same household as Tolen.

Tolen was arrested Dec. 22 and released the next day on a $1,500 bond. On conviction, the charge carries a sentence of up to 93 days in jail and/or a $500,000 fine.

In 2010, while she was on probation for impaired driving in Leelanau County, Tolen was arrested in St. Joseph for drinking and driving.

Police reported she had a blood-alcohol level three times the legal limit.

That case was moved to St. Joseph County, and Tolen served 20 days in jail after being convicted on the charge.

Sepic told WNDU-TV that he has petitioned the state attorney general's office to disqualify his office from the most recent case because of Tolen's previous position with the court.


Friday, March 26, 2010

03262010 - Deputy Nick Cavanaugh - Terminated - Otsego County SD



On March 26, 2010, Otsego County Sheriff Jim McBride dismissed Deputy Nick Cavanaugh from the Sheriff Department for "a major policy violation". It was not the first time Sheriff McBride had reprimanded or dismissed Deputy Cavanaugh.



ALSO SEE:
DEPUTY NICK CAVANAUGH, OTSEGO COUNTY SD. February 14, 2004:
domestic violence incident; drunk driving; loaded gun.



DEPUTY NICK CAVANAUGH, OTSEGO COUNTY SD. August 2003:
Reprimanded for taking confiscated fireworks for own personal use.











Sheriff’s deputy fired for ‘major violation’
April 06, 2010
By Michael Jones, Staff writer
Petoskey News
http://articles.petoskeynews.com/2010-04-06/road-patrol-deputy_24094016

GAYLORD - Less than one week after the Otsego County Sheriff’s Department (OCSD) fired 11-year veteran deputy Nick Cavanaugh March 26 for “a major policy violation,” Sheriff Jim McBride said his department received a letter from Cavanaugh stating his intention to seek arbitration to get his job back.

Because of the pending request for arbitration McBride said he could not comment on the reason for the dismissal of the 35-year-old deputy, who had been placed on a paid administrative leave March 9 prior to his March 26 termination with the department.

McBride did say he had reviewed the personnel issue incident involving Cavanaugh with the prosecutor’s office before making his decision to terminate the road patrol deputy. The sheriff said the issue concerning Cavanaugh’s dismissal was not a criminal matter.

He indicated the firing had nothing to do with Cavanaugh’s credibility as a witness in a recently completed trial heard by Judge Janet M. Allen in 46th Circuit Court. The trial, which began March 16, resulted in a mistrial March 29 when jurors were unable come to reach a verdict in the assault with intent to murder against defendant James Platte Jr.

Cavanaugh was a witness for the prosecution in that trial.

This is not the first time Cavanaugh has been in trouble with the OCSD nor the first time he has been fired by McBride.

In 2004, McBride terminated Cavanaugh after reviewing a police report relating to an alleged off-duty incident in Gladwin involving the deputy.

According to a February 2004 incident report from the Gladwin City Police, officers allegedly found Cavanaugh in possession of his department-issued handgun while intoxicated inside a parked vehicle at a private parking lot in Gladwin. The weapon was allegedly located by officers on the backseat floor of the vehicle under a jacket.

The four-page report was later forwarded to the Gladwin County prosecutor’s office for review. Gladwin County Prosecutor Thomas Jones declined to bring charges against Cavanaugh for the alleged incident, indicating there was not sufficient evidence to bring charges.

According to the incident report, Cavanaugh allegedly blew a .17 on a preliminary breath test. The report indicated Cavanaugh had not been arrested and authorities reportedly transported him to an area motel. In a Feb. 25, 2004 letter, Jones questioned numerous procedural matters found in the report as part of the basis for his decision not to charge Cavanaugh.

After the OCSD was informed of the incident the deputy was placed on administrative leave and then fired two days later. Despite not being charged in the February 2004 incident, McBride indicted Cavanaugh’s alleged behavior was sufficient grounds for termination and had been preceded by several other incidents during Cavanaugh’s then five-year tenure with the department.

In the summer of 2003, Cavanaugh had been suspended for his alleged involvement with another deputy for keeping confiscated fireworks for their own personal use. The other deputy, Jeffrey Brecheisen, was fired from the department as a result of the incident.



Michigan Officer Involved Domestic Violence

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

03172010 - Terrance Kiernan - Ex wife Unadilla Township Supervisor Linda Walker

Terence Kiernan held his ex-wife, Linda Walker [Unadilla Township Supervisor] at gunpoint. The gun was later found to be unloaded. He is now serving out a at a 13 year prison sentence.


Meanwhile, Michigan police officers, who commit more severe acts of domestic violence involving the use of firearms, do not serve prison terms. Instead, police officers facing felony domestic violence charges are having their cases pled down under MCL 769.4a. Under MCL 769.4a [Michigan's loophole to the Lautenberg Amendment], an officer serves no prison time, and the officer's felony domestic violence charge is expunged after one year and the officer can re-join his police department.

The felony domestic violence case against Officer Steele [Detroit PD], comes to mind:
http://michiganoidv.blogspot.com/2008/03/officer-gary-steele-detroit-pd-030408.html


Faced with multiple felony dv charges and a possible life sentence, Officer Gary Steele had his case plea bargained down under MCL 769.4a. Officer Steele is currently back on the Detroit Police Department.

If MCL769.4a wasn't intentionally amended to become a loophole specifically for police officers facing felony domestic violence charges...then why wasn't this plea bargain available to Terence Kiernan? Why is Kiernan behind bars for thirteen years and Officer Steele is not only a free man, but is once again wearing the badge?





Terrance Shawn Kiernan




Unadilla Township Supervisor, Linda Walker





















Man pleads to holding his ex-wife at gunpoint
Detroit News
July 17, 2010
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
A 52-year-old Unadilla Township man pleaded guilty Friday to holding his ex-wife at gunpoint in her Fowlerville law office in March.

Prosecutors agreed to recommend no more than five years in prison when Terence Kiernan is sentenced Aug. 26.

Authorities said Kiernan pointed a handgun at his ex-wife and demanded she return pension benefits she receives through their divorce settlement.

He faced several charges, including extortion and carrying a concealed weapon.















Man accused of holding ex at gunpoint to go to trial
Detroit News
April 22, 2010
A Unadilla Township man accused of holding his ex-wife at gunpoint in a divorce dispute will be tried in Livingston Circuit Court. Terence Kiernan, 52, waived his right to a preliminary exam Wednesday in 53rd District Court in Howell. He is being held on $1 million bond for allegedly threatening to kill Linda Walker, an attorney and township supervisor, last month unless she agreed to give back half of his pension. Kiernan could get life in prison on six charges, including assault with intent to murder.















Judge decides not to reduce the bond in gun-threat case
Detroit News
April 15, 2010
Fowlerville -  A judge Wednesday declined to lower the $1 million bond for a Unadilla Township man who allegedly held his ex-wife at gunpoint. Terence Kiernan, 52, is being held in Livingston County Jail for the March 17 incident. He is accused of threatening Linda Walker, a local attorney and Unadilla Township supervisor, because she received half of his pension in a divorce settlement. He will be in court at 8:30 a.m. Wednesday for a preliminary exam.
















Charges changed in case of Unadilla woman held at gunpoint
BY LISA ROOSE-CHURCH
DAILY PRESS and ARGUS 
March 24, 2010
http://www.livingstondaily.com/article/20100324/NEWS01/100324012/Charges-changed-in-case-of-Unadilla-woman-held-at-gunpoint
The Livingston County prosecutor’s office revised charges against a Unadilla Township man accused of holding his former wife at gunpoint at her law office in Fowlerville.

Terence Shawn Kiernan, 52, was initially charged in Livingston County District Court with assault with intent to commit murder for allegedly holding his ex-wife, Unadilla Township Supervisor Linda Walker, at gunpoint at her law office on Grand River Avenue in Fowlerville.

However, Prosecutor David Morse revised the charge today to extortion after learning the weapon was not loaded.

Morse said to prove the assault charge he would have had to show that Kiernan had intent to kill Walker, but without a loaded gun that intent disappears.

Kiernan also is charged with felonious assault and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony, carrying a concealed weapon, drunken driving and possession of a firearm under the influence of alcohol.

Kiernan, who is being held in the Livingston County Jail on a $1 million bond, returns to District Court on April 14 for an exam conference.

Walker said she had just returned from lunch March 17 when Kiernan came into her law office shortly after 1 p.m., and pointed a revolver at her. She said she begged him “not to kill me,” and wrestled with him for the gun, but he knocked her to the ground and held the gun at her head.

Walker said Kiernan was angry with her because she receives a portion of his pension benefits through their divorce agreement. She said Kiernan demanded that she return the benefits.
















Cops: Divorce deal provoked assault on Unadilla Twp. official
The Detroit News
Valerie Olander
Last Updated: March 20. 2010 1:00AM
http://detnews.com/article/20100320/METRO/3200328/Cops--Divorce-deal-provoked-assault-on-Unadilla-Twp.-official
Fowlerville --The newly ex-husband of Unadilla Township's supervisor is accused of threatening her at gunpoint this week after a divorce settlement gave her half his pension.

Terence Shawn Kiernan, 52, was in the Livingston County Jail on $1 million bond Friday, one day after he was charged with assault with intent to murder and a host of other charges.

Fowlerville Police Chief Tom Couling said Kiernan confronted Linda Walker, who is a lawyer and the Unadilla Township supervisor, at her office about 1 p.m. Wednesday and threatened to kill her.

"He had a handgun pointed to her head and threatened to kill her unless she gave back his pension money," Couling said.

The divorce settlement was finalized last week in Livingston Circuit Court.

At one point, Walker grabbed the gun and a short scuffle ensued, Couling said.

Kiernan left after she agreed to let him have the money.

She called 911.

Unadilla Township Police stopped Kiernan a short time later and found the weapon, a semiautomatic handgun, in his car.

He also was arrested on suspicion of drunken driving, Couling said.

Police are not saying whether the gun was loaded.

Walker did not return phone calls seeking comment.

Kiernan is charged with assault with intent to murder, felonious assault, felony firearm, carrying a concealed weapon, operating a vehicle while intoxicated and possession of a firearm while under the influence.

Kiernan returns Wednesday to 53rd District Court for an exam conference.
















Man points gun at ex-wife over divorce dispute, police say
The Detroit News
Valerie Olander
Last Updated: March 19. 2010 7:02PM
http://www.detnews.com/article/20100319/METRO04/3190412/1015/rss04

Howell -- A Unadilla Township man is being held in the Livingston County Jail today on $1 million bond after being charged Thursday with allegedly holding his ex-wife at gunpoint at her Fowlerville law office.

Terence Shawn Kiernan, 52, was angered by a divorce settlement finalized last week and walked into the law office with a gun shortly after 1 p.m. Wednesday, Fowlerville Police Chief Tom Couling said.

His ex-wife, Linda Walker, a local attorney and Unadilla Township supervisor, had been awarded half of his pension in the settlement.

"He had a handgun pointed to her head and threatened to kill her unless she gave back his pension money," Couling said.

At one point, Walker grabbed the gun and a short scuffle ensued, Couling said.

Kiernan left after she agreed to let him have the money. She called 911.

Unadilla Township Police stopped Kiernan a short time later and found the weapon, a semi automatic handgun, in his car. He was also arrested on suspicion of drunken driving, Couling said.

Police are not saying whether the gun was loaded.

Kiernan is charged with assault with intent to murder, felonious assault, felony firearm, carrying a concealed weapon, operating a vehicle while intoxicated and possession of a firearm while under the influence.

Kiernan returns to 53rd District Court March 24 for an exam conference.
















Local Attorney and Township Supervisor Held at Gun-Point By Ex-Husband
March 18, 2010
WHMI 93.5 FM Radio Station, Livingston County MI
http://www.whmi.com/news/article/9858
A Unadilla Township man is jailed and awaiting charges for allegedly holding his ex-wife at gunpoint Wednesday.

52 year old Terence Shawn Kiernan was arrested by Unadilla Township Police after his ex-wife, Fowlerville Attorney and Unadilla Township Supervisor Linda Walker, called 911 and said he had attacked and threatened to kill her.

Walker says that when she returned to her law office shortly after 1pm, Kiernan came in the back door and pulled out a gun. Walker reportedly wrestled with Kiernan for the gun but he knocked her to the ground and held the gun to her head, threatening to kill her. Kiernan was allegedly angry because Walker received a portion of his pension benefits through their divorce agreement. He then fled the office after Walker agreed to return the pension benefits. As soon as he left, Walker called 911.

Fowlerville Police Chief Tom Couling tells WHMI that a be-on-the-lookout alert was issued and Tiernan was arrested a short time later by Unadilla Township Police on Donahue Road. Couling says a small handgun was recovered and they are seeking charges of felonious assault against Tiernan, who remains lodged in the Livingston County Jail. (JK)



Monday, March 1, 2010

03012010 - Judge Lynda Tolen - Berrien County [retired]


Also See: Arrested for domestic violence
http://michiganoidv.blogspot.com/2011/12/judge-lynda-tolen-berrien-county-retired.html



Retired Berrien County Judge Lynda Tolen: Arrested for a second drunk driving offense in 2010, while on probation for first drunk driving offense.


2010: Arrested and charged for drunk driving. Placed on probation.

2010: Arrested for a second drunk driving charge while on probation for first DUI. Setenced to 20 days in jail.

November 30, 2010: State of Michigan suspended Tolen's license to practice law for 180 days [due to her DUI convictions].

December 22, 2011: Arrested for domestic violence.









Former judge in front of bench again
Lynda Tolen arraigned on domestic violence charge
Posted: Friday, December 30, 2011 12:00 am
Herald Palladium
http://www.heraldpalladium.com/localnews/former-judge-in-front-of-bench-again/article_4aa0a047-5eb1-5bac-b81c-aa597392e046.html

ST. JOSEPH - Retired Berrien County Trial Court Judge Lynda Tolen, who has faced drunk driving charges in the past, was back in court this week on charges of domestic violence.

Tolen, 60, of Stevensville, who retired in 2008 after 21 years as a judge, was arraigned Tuesday on the misdemeanor charge, according to a report from WNDU-TV.

The complaint, which Chief Assistant Prosecutor Michael Sepic showed to The Herald-Palladium, stated that Tolen had assaulted a woman named Lisa Brasseur.

The complaint lists Brasseur as a resident or former resident of the same household as Tolen.

Tolen was arrested Dec. 22 and released the next day on a $1,500 bond. On conviction, the charge carries a sentence of up to 93 days in jail and/or a $500,000 fine.

In 2010, while she was on probation for impaired driving in Leelanau County, Tolen was arrested in St. Joseph for drinking and driving.

Police reported she had a blood-alcohol level three times the legal limit.

That case was moved to St. Joseph County, and Tolen served 20 days in jail after being convicted on the charge.

Sepic told WNDU-TV that he has petitioned the state attorney general's office to disqualify his office from the most recent case because of Tolen's previous position with the court.


Friday, February 26, 2010

02262010 - Former MSP Trooper Bart Cunningham - Shot/Wounded Wife And Teenage Stepson Before Committing Suicide









Former Michigan State Trooper Bart Cunningham shot and critically wounded his wife Wendy and his teenage step-son Joshua Snyder. Cunningham then committed suicide. Wendy's and Bart's teenage daughter was unharmed in the shootings and was able to call 911.












Ionia shooting leaves two injured, gunman dead
WZZM13 Grand Rapids
February 26, 2010
http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/article/20100226/NEWS01/302260011/-1/newshome/

IONIA - Two people are wounded and a third is dead after a triple shooting in Ionia.

The gunman is dead and is believed to have committed suicide, according to police.

Police say that a 13-year-old girl called police at about 4 a.m. Friday to report the shooting. Two people were taken to Spectrum Health in Grand Rapids with multiple gunshot wounds. There is no word on their conditions.

The incident happened in the 400 block of Baldie Street.

Officers closed off four city blocks surrounding the crime scene and streets. Sts. Peter and Paul School, which is located near the crime scene, closed Friday because of the shooting.

Names of the victims or the gunman have not yet been released and police are still investigating.












Three people taken to hospital after early morning shooting, standoff in Ionia
The Grand Rapids Press
February 26, 2010
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2010/02/three_people_taken_to_hospital.html

Update at 8:45 a.m.: Ionia police say one person, believed to be the gunman, has died.

A police officer walks in front of the home at 418 Baldie Street in Ionia where three people were shot early this morning. [Dave Odette. The Grand Rapids Press]


IONIA -- Police are investigating an early morning shooting that sent three people to the hospital.

Ionia Public Safety Director David Bulling said officers were called to the 400 block of Baldie Street about 4:30 this morning on reports of gunshots.

Police were in contact with a person inside the house, and it was determined the shooter was still inside. Bulling said active gunshots were heard and the special operations unit was called in.

The street just south of M-21 was shut down as the team entered the house.

Police found three people wounded, one believed to be the shooter.

Identities and conditions of the victims are unavailable at this time.

Police set up a command post down the street in the parking lot of Saints Peter and Paul Church and School.

The school was closed for the day as a precaution, Bulling said. Ambulances were leaving the scene about 6:30 a.m. and the area was secure.

"The neighborhood is safe," Bulling said.












Neighbors shocked by shooting in Ionia
The Grand Rapids Press
February 26, 2010
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2010/02/neighbors_shocked_by_shooting.html


Rex Larsen The Grand Rapids Press. Barbara Lower, 83, who lives on Baldie Street in Ionia near the scene of a fatal shooting this morning, recalled the seeing the children from that house playing in the neighborhood as they grew up across the street from her.


IONIA -- Across the street from the Baldie Street home where three people were shot Friday morning, Barbara Lower and her friend, Mary Helwig, of Carson City, watched police investigate and wrap crime-scene tape around the house.

Both women know the family and were stunned to hear what happened.

Neighbors reported a family of four, parents and two children, live 418 Baldie Street where the shooting occurred. They were concerned about the children, but heard the kids were OK. Police were not releasing the victims' names or ages but said a 13-year-old girl, who was not hurt, called 911.

"It's shocking, especially in a neighborhood like this," Lower, 83, said.

Helwig, also 83, in town to visit her daughter and grandchildren, said it was hard to imagine such a tragedy with children in the house.

"It's just a sad situation. You don't expect it in a small town like this."












Suspected gunman dies after Ionia shooting, two others seriously injured
The Grand Rapids Press
February 26, 2010
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2010/02/suspected_gunman_dies_after_io.html

An Ionia police officer walks in front of the home at 418 Baldie Street in Ionia where three people were shot multiple times early this morning. [Dave Odette The Grand Rapids Press.]


IONIA -- Police say one person is dead and two others seriously injured, in this morning's shooting inside a house at 418 Baldie St.

The deceased is believed to be the gunman. The victims had been shot multiple times, police said. All of those involved were related, police said.

A 13-year-old girl, who was not hurt, called 911, and stayed on with the dispatchers throughout the ordeal.

"She was able to give us updates as this progressed, and she was very helpful," Ionia Public Safety Director David Bulling said.

Police say the names of those involved will not be released until this afternoon.

A neighbor said family of four, parents and two children, lived at the home. The neighbor didn't know details about the shooting but said said police told her neighborhood was safe this morning.

A critical-response team, comprised of Ionia police and Ionia County sheriff's deputies, responded to the scene, but police did not fire any shots, Bulling said.












Two Shot in Ionia Home
WLNS NEWS
Feb 26, 2010
http://www.wlns.com/Global/story.asp?S=12050266

One man is dead, his wife and stepson injured after an early morning shooting. It happened in Ionia on the 400 block of Baldie Street.

We now know that the shooter is 37 year old Bart Cunningham. Police say he shot his wife and sixteen year old stepson multiple times before killing himself.

They say an argument occurred before the shootings. After that, the couple's thirteen year old daughter called 911.

The police chief says this isn't the first time they've been called to Cunningham's home, but the chief wouldn't say why they had been there before. This time he says it took the swat team fifty minutes to get inside the home with the help of the

David Bulling, Ionia Police Chief: "We were communicating with a thirteen year old on the phone to determine what the situation was and getting our team ready and deployed to go in and make an entry of the home, not knowing what the status of the shooter was."

The thirteen year old girl was not injured. Police say she is safe and staying with family. Both victims are in a Grand Rapids hospital, listed in serious condition with non-life threatening injuries. It's unknown whether drugs or alcohol were involved, but the Michigan State Police are still investigating this tragedy.












Victims identified in early morning Ionia shooting
Ionia Sentinel-Standard staff
Fri Feb 26, 2010
http://www.sentinel-standard.com/news/x593978943/Three-shot-in-supposed-domestic-dispute

MSP mobile crime lab is stationed outside the house in the 400 block of Baldie Street where the shooting incident took place early Friday morning.


IDPS Detective Sergeant John Odette and IDPS Director David Bulling are inside the IDPS Mobile Command Center stationed outside the residence where the shooting took place. Photo by Ionia Sentinel Standard.


IONIA - Ionia Department of Public Safety Officers responded to shots fired in a residence in the 400 block of Baldie Street at approximately 4:30 a.m. today.

The caller, a 13 year-old female, was in the residence at the time of the shooting, and Central Dispatch stayed on the line with her during the ordeal, and IDPS officers were able to obtain information, according to IDPS Director David Bulling.

Officers secured the perimeter, and heard one shot fired. They called in Ionia County Critical Incident Team, which is made of IDPS officers and Ionia County Sheriff’s Office deputies.

When the Incident Team made entry, they found two victims, Wendy Suzanne Cunningham, 42, and her 16-year-old son and “step-son” to the shooter, with multiple gun shots wounds.

They were flown to Spectrum Health Hospital in Grand Rapids, and are currently in non-life threatening, critical condition, according to Bulling.

The 13-year-old was not injured, and is currently staying with relatives.

The shooter, Bart Fredrick Cunningham, 37, who was found deceased in the basement with a self-inflicted gunshot wound. He was a former Michigan State Police trooper at the Kalkaska Post 79 from '96 to '04 when he resigned.

The IDPS waited 50 minutes until the perimeter was secure and for the Critical Team to arrive. During that time they stayed connected with the 13-year-old female. During this time they had reason to believe that she was in a safe location.

There were no shots fired from law enforcement officers, and the Michigan State Police Crime Lab is currently investigating the crime scene.

The cause of the shooting seems to have stemmed from a domestic dispute, according to Bulling.












Ionia shooting victims identified; gunman committed suicide in domestic dispute
The Grand Rapids Press
February 26, 2010
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2010/02/ionia_shooting_victims_identif.html

UPDATE: Police say Ionia teen was on phone with 911 as former Michigan state trooper shot stepson, her mother, himself.

Wendy Cunningham, 42, and her son, Joshua Snyder, 16, were shot multiple times this morning by Bart Cunningham, 37, at 418 Baldie Street in Ionia. Rex Larsen The Grand Rapids Press.


IONIA -- Police have identified the man who shot and killed himself inside his Ionia home today as Bart Cunningham, 37. He is a former state police trooper who pleaded guilty to a sex crime in 2003.

Cunningham shot and seriously injured both his wife, Wendy Cunningham, 42, and her 16-year-old son, police said. The boy's name is Joshua Snyder. Both were in serious condition this afternoon at Spectrum Health Butterworth Hospital.

The incident started as a domestic dispute, police said.

Bart Cunningham enlisted as a state police trooper in 1996, but resigned in 2004 while assigned to the Kalkaska post.

In 2002, Kalkaska police arrested Cunningham on a high-court misdemeanor of fourth-degree criminal-sexual conduct, state police records show. He pleaded guilty in 2003 to assault and battery and attempted fourth-degree criminal-sexual conduct and was sentenced to 18 months on probation.

In late December 2007, he was arrested in Ionia for domestic violence. He was sentenced to 12 days in jail and 12 months on probation.












Ionia gunman was former Michigan state trooper
WWMT TV News
February 26, 2010
http://www.wwmt.com/articles/margin-1373169-ionia-bottom.html


Bart Cunningham


IONIA, Mich. (NEWSCHANNEL 3) – More information is emerging about a triple shooting in Ionia.

The investigation began around 4:30 Friday morning with a 911 call being placed from a home in the 400 block of Baldie Street in Ionia.

Police say a man there shot two of his family members, then shot and killed himself. Now, News channel 3 has learned that the gunman was a former Michigan State Trooper.

Bart Cunningham was a state trooper in Kalkaska until he was charged with criminal sexual conduct. Cunningham resigned in 2004.

In 2008, there was a domestic violence case at the home on Baldie Street, then Friday morning saw more violence.

“It's a terrible, terrible thing that happened,” said neighbor Barbara Lower.

Lower awoke Friday morning to flashing lights across from her home on Baldie Street. She'd seen her neighbors before, but didn't know 37-year-old Bart Cunningham, or his family.

“Never any trouble I could see at all,” said Lower.

However police say around 4:30 Friday morning Cunningham got into an argument with his family members and pulled a gun, shooting his wife, 42-year-old Wendy Cunningham, and 16-year-old stepson.

Cunningham's thirteen-year-old daughter called 911.

“She was giving us what she could hear from her location in the upstairs room,” said David Bulling of the Ionia Department of Public Safety.

It took nearly an hour before the SWAT team went into the house.

“Wendy Cunningham was found upstairs with multiple gunshot wounds,” said Bulling.

Both Wendy Cunningham and her son were rushed to the hospital where they are in serious condition, but their wounds are not considered life-threatening.

Investigators say they found Bart Cunningham's body in the basement.

“He died from self-inflicted gunshot wounds,” said Bulling.

Police say they didn't know whether Bart Cunningham was alive or dead when they went into the house Friday morning, which is why they needed a SWAT team to enter the house.

Police now believe Cunningham was deceased when they arrived.












Former MSP trooper shoots 2, kills self
Everybody is related

WOOD TV News
Feb 26, 2010
http://www.woodtv.com/dpp/news/local/central_mich/shooting-in-ionia


Former Michigan State Police trooper Bart Cunningham shot his wife and child before killing himself at their Ionia home. File photo


Police in front of a house on Baldie Street in Ionia where two people were shot and one person killed himself.


Police at a home in the 400 block of Baldie Street in Ionia where a shooting occurred. 


Emergency personnel at the staging area -- Saints Peter and Paul Catholic School -- after a shooting occurred at a nearby house on Baldie Street in Ionia. 


Police at the staging area -- Saints Peter and Paul Catholic School -- after a shooting occurred at a nearby house on Baldie Street in Ionia.


IONIA, Mich. (WOOD) - Investigators identified Bart Cunningham, 37, Friday afternoon as the man who shot two relatives at their Ionia home early Friday morning before committing suicide.

Cunnningham's wife, 42-year-old Wendy Cunningham, and her 16-year-old son were shot multiple times but are expected to live Ionia Public Safety Director David Bulling said Friday afternoon.

Bulling said the incident was the result of a domestic situation, but did not release further details.

Bart Cunningham was a former Michigan State Police trooper, a department spokeswoman told 24 Hour News 8. He had served only at the Kalkaska Post and resigned in 2004, she said.

The 37-year-old has a fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct conviction on his record, tied to a May 2002 incident. A jury convicted him on a charge of domestic violence against Wendy Cunningham based on a December 2007 incident.

Court records of the 2007 incident obtained by 24 Hour News 8 show Wendy Cunningham called police claiming to have been assaulted,but officers testified they did not find any evidence of injury. In court, Wendy Cunningham said he grabbed at her hand but she did not remember much of the incident. Bart Cunningham testified that he tried to grab his wife's purse and she hit him back.

Public safety officers were first called to the home in the 400 block of Baldie Street east of downtown Ionia around 4:30 a.m.

"Once officers were on scene, they were able to make contact with a 13-year-old that was still in the home," Bulling said Friday morning. The 13-year-old was Bart and Wendy Cunningham's daughter, investigators said, and was not hurt in the incidents. She is now staying with other relatives, they said.

Roughly 50 minutes later, the county's critical incident team -- made up of public safety officers and sheriff's department personnel -- entered the home, Bulling said. Investigators found "one deceased individual," he said. "At this time, the initial investigation has shown that person to be the shooter."

The two victims had multiple gunshot wounds and were taken from the scene by air, he said.

The Michigan State Police crime lab was called to the scene to investigate.

Some streets in the area were closed for a time and nearby Saints Peter and Paul school, which served as a staging area for police, canceled school Friday.












One dead, two wounded in Ionia shooting
WZZM CHANNEL 13 NEWS
February 26, 2010
http://www.wzzm13.com/news/local/story.aspx?storyid=118933

Baldie Street


IONIA, Mich. (WZZM) - Public safety officers are investigating a triple shooting in Ionia.

It happened in the 400 block of Baldie Street.

Police say that a 13-year-old girl called police at about 4:00am Friday to report the shooting.

"She was giving us what she could based on what she could hear fro her location in an upstairs room," said Ionia Public Safety Director Dave Bulling.

A swat team entered and found two people, 42-year-old Wendy Cunningham and her 16-year-old son, upstairs shot multiple times. They found the shooter, 37-year-old Bart Frederick Cunningham, downstairs, dead after an apparent suicide.

Cunningham and her son were taken to Spectrum Health in Grand Rapids in serious condition, but with non-life threatening injuries.

Officers closed off four city blocks surrounding the crime scene and streets. Sts. Peter and Paul School, which is located near the crime scene, closed Friday because of the shooting.

The 13-year-old girl, the couple's daughter together, was not injured and is staying with family members.












Police say Ionia teen was on phone with 911 as former Michigan state trooper shot stepson, her mother, himself
The Grand Rapids Press
February 26, 2010
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2010/02/police_say_ionia_teen_was_on_p.html

A body is removed Friday from an Ionia on Baldie Street where police say a mother and son were shot by a former state police trooper. Police say the shooter killed himself in the home. Rex Larsen. The Grand Rapids Press. 

IONIA -- In the little city of Ionia, the Cunningham family has long been a well-known part of the community.

But inside their tidy white house early Friday, authorities say a domestic nightmare played out.

While a 13-year-old girl hid in a bedroom, she relayed to emergency dispatchers the deadly events she could hear transpiring beyond her locked door.

Former Trooper Bart Cunningham


Police say Bart Cunningham, 37, a former state police trooper, shot and injured his stepson, 16-year-old Joshua Snyder, and the teen's mother, 42-year-old Wendy Cunningham. Bart Cunningham then fatally turned the gun on himself, police said.

Authorities were alerted to the incident about 4:30 a.m., when Joshua's younger sister inside the home called police.

She helped provide information for members of an Ionia County tactical team, which took about an hour before entering the home at 418 Baldie St., said David Bulling, director of the Ionia Department of Public Safety.

In the house, police found Bart Cunningham dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound, and the mother and son suffering from multiple gunshot wounds. Police say two guns were likely involved.

Ionia shooting press conference
Wendy Cunningham and her son were taken by helicopter to Spectrum Health Butterworth Hospital.

They were listed in serious condition.

The incident started as a domestic dispute, police said.


Barb Lower, 83, lives near the home where the shooting occurred. Rex Larsen The Grand Rapids Press. 

Barb Lower, 83, who lives across the street from the Cunninghams, said she would see their children playing and riding skateboards. "It's shocking, especially in a neighborhood like this," said Lower, who has lived in the house for more than 50 years.

Bart Cunningham enlisted as a state police trooper in 1996, but resigned in 2004 while assigned to the Kalkaska post.

In 2002, Kalkaska police arrested Cunningham on a high-court misdemeanor of fourth-degree criminal-sexual conduct, state police records show. He pled guilty in 2003 to assault and battery and attempted fourth-degree criminal-sexual conduct, and was sentenced to 18 months on probation.

In late December 2007, he was arrested in Ionia for domestic violence. He was sentenced to 12 days in jail, and 12 months on probation.

Court records show Wendy Cunningham also has had recent brushes with the law.

Wendy Cunningham had a 2004 conviction for domestic violence, and 2008 conviction for allowing alcohol or drug consumption by minors. Records showed she was arrested last year for using false or forged prescriptions to obtain controlled substances.

Early Friday, police called Ionia Public Schools leaders, letting them know what had happened, according to Ben Kirby, an assistant superintendent.

The schools on Friday tried to help students and teachers who know the teens involved, and also to stem the tide of speculation that flooded student cell phones, which are supposed to be kept in lockers.

Kirby said counselors will remain in place Monday and that the two students are long-time members of the school community.

"There is quite a connection in the community with that family," said Kirby.

"The kids are well-known and well-respected among students and teachers, as well."












Fmr. State Trooper Responsible for Ionia Shootings
WLNS NEWS
Feb 27, 2010
http://www.wlns.com/Global/story.asp?S=12055229

An early morning shooting in Ionia leaves one man dead and his wife and stepson injured. It happened on the 400 block of Baldie Street. Police say 37 year old Bart Cunningham shot his wife and sixteen year old stepson multiple times, before killing himself. Cunningham is a former state trooper. Grand Rapids TV station WOOD reports that he resigned in 2004 and has a previous conviction for domestic violence.

Authorities say the couple was arguing before the shootings and that the couple's thirteen year old daughter called 911. The police chief says it took 50 minutes for the SWAT team to get inside the home with the help of that daughter.

David Bulling, Ionia Police Chief: "We were communicating with a thirteen year old on the phone to determine what the situation was and getting our team ready and deployed to go in and make an entry of the home, not knowing what the status of the shooter was."

The thirteen year old girl was not injured. Both shooting victims are in a Grand Rapids hospital listed in serious condition.












Ionia shooting victims continue to recover
MLive
February 27, 2010
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2010/02/ionia_shooting_victims_continu.html

IONIA -- Medical conditions for Wendy Cunningham and her son, Joshua Snyder, have been upgraded to fair.

Cunningham, 42, and Snyder, 16, are recovering at Spectrum Health Butterworth Hospital after being shot during an apparent domestic dispute.

Cunningham's husband, former state police trooper Bart Cunningham, 37, had shot them multiple times and took his own life in the Friday morning incident; he had pleaded guilty to a sex crime charge in 2003.

A 13-year-old girl in the home at the time of the shootings was spared. She called 911 and stayed on the phone with dispatchers during the ordeal.

Ionia police said Saturday afternoon the case, which stunned neighbors, had no new developments.












Friday’s victims in stable condition
The Ionia Sentinel-Standard
Mar 01, 2010
http://www.sentinel-standard.com/news/police_and_fire/x1520842961/Friday-s-victims-in-stable-condition

IONIA, Mich. -Two victims who were shot multiple times early Friday morning are expected to make a full recovery, according to Ionia Public Safety Department officers.

"The conditions have been upgraded to stable condition for both parties,” said IDPS Detective Sergeant John Odette.

Wendy Suzanne Cunningham and her 16-year-old son were hospitalized after being shot by her husband, Bart Cunningham, during a supposed domestic dispute, according to IDPS officers.

The preliminary autopsy report on Bart Cunningham showed that it was a self-inflicted single shot with a small caliber that took his life. 

Tests are still being done to check for alcohol or drug use.

A prayer service will be held 1 p.m. Thursday at St. John the Baptist Catholic Church in Hubbardston for Bart Cunningham. Visitation and lunch will follow the services at the Church Hall.

The family is asking all who attend the service to wear camouflage in memory of Cunningham.












Bart F. Cunningham
[April 2, 1972 - February 26, 2010]
Schrauben-Lehman Funeral Homes
http://www.webfh.com/fh/obituaries/obituary.cfm?o_id=294976&fh_id=10349&ck=1

Born April 2, 1972 to Russ and Mary Jo (Tomac) Cunningham left us unexpectantly Friday, February 26, 2010. Bart had been currently working for CSX Railroad for the past 7 years. He is survived by his wife, Wendy (Snyder) Cunningham; children, Joshua and Hunter; parents, Russ and Carolyn Cunningham; step father, Art Lower; In-laws, Cathy and Al Gosdzinksi; brother, Russ (Michele) Cunningham, Jr.; sisters, Corey (Jason) Werner, Chelsea (Taylor) Thelen, Cassidy Cunningham, Angela (Bob) Lusk, and Rachel (Ryan) Lammer; sister-in-law, Stacy (Frank) Shepanski; nieces and nephews, McKenna and Madison Cunningham, Whitney and Wyatt Werner, Hailey Lusk, Justin and Karly Lammer, and Chelsea Shepanski; also many aunts, uncles, and cousins. He was preceded in death by his mother, Mary Jo Tomac; grandparents, Bill and Virginia Cunningham, and Steve Tomac; 3 great friends, Kevin King, Chris Sawtell, and Danon Pierce. Bart left us with many great memories. He was a man with a huge heart. Always there to help anyone with anything. He loved the outdoors; hunting, trapping, fishing, playing cards, throwing washers, spending time with his bestfriend and father, Russ and many special friends - way too many to name.

A prayer service will be held at 1 p.m. Thursday, March 4, 2010 at St. John the Baptist Catholic Church, Hubbardston, MI. Visitation and Lunch will follow the services at the Church Hall.

In lieu of flowers, memorial contributions may be made to the Joshua and Hunter Cunningham Educational Fund in memory of Bart F. Cunningham.

In memory of Bart, the family is asking for all that attend the service, that you wear camoflauge.

Arrangements are entrusted to the Schrauben-Lehman Funeral Homes, Ionia. Online condolences may be made at www.schraubenlehman.com












Obituary: Bart F. Cunningham of Ionia
The Ionia Sentinel-Standard
Mar 01, 2010
http://www.sentinel-standard.com/obituaries/x1520842947/Obituary-Bart-F-Cunningham-of-Ionia



IONIA, Mich. -Bart F. Cunningham of Ionia, born April 2, 1972, to Russ and Mary Jo (Tomac) Cunningham, left us unexpectantly Friday, Feb, 26, 2010. Bart had been currently working for CSX Railroad for the past seven years.

He is survived by his wife, Wendy (Snyder) Cunningham; children, Joshua and Hunter; parents, Russ and Carolyn Cunningham; step father, Art Lower; in-laws, Cathy and Al Gosdzinksi; brother, Russ (Michele) Cunningham Jr.; sisters, Corey (Jason) Werner, Chelsea (Taylor) Thelen, Cassidy Cunningham, Angela (Bob) Lusk, and Rachel (Ryan) Lammer; sister-in-law, Stacy (Frank) Shepanski; nieces and nephews, McKenna and Madison Cunningham, Whitney and Wyatt Werner, Hailey Lusk, Justin and Karly Lammer, and Chelsea Shepanski; also many aunts, uncles, and cousins.

He was preceded in death by his mother, Mary Jo Tomac; grandparents, Bill and Virginia Cunningham, and Steve Tomac; three great friends, Kevin King, Chris Sawtell and Danon Pierce.

Bart left us with many great memories. He was a man with a huge heart. Always there to help anyone with anything. He loved the outdoors; hunting, trapping, fishing, playing cards, throwing washers, spending time with his bestfriend and father, Russ and many special friends – way too many to name.

A prayer service will be held at 1 p.m. Thursday, March 4, 2010, at St. John the Baptist Catholic Church, Hubbardston.

Visitation and lunch will follow the services at the Church Hall.


In memory of Bart, the family is asking for all that attend the service, that you wear camoflauge.

In lieu of flowers, memorial contributions may be made to the Joshua and Hunter Cunningham Educational Fund, in memory of Bart F. Cunningham.

Arrangements are entrusted to the Schrauben-Lehman Funeral Homes, Ionia. Online condolences may be made at http://www.schraubenlehman.com/.













Recovery continues for Ionia shooting victims
The Grand Rapids Press staff
March 03, 2010, 9:07PM
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2010/03/recovery_continues_for_ionia_s.html

GRAND RAPIDS -- Wendy Cunningham and Joshua Snyder continue recovering from being shot multiple times during an apparent domestic dispute in their Ionia home on Friday.

Wendy Cunningham, 42, was transferred Wednesday from Spectrum Health Butterworth Hospital to the Mary Free Bed Rehabilitation Hospital. Her son, Joshua Snyder, 16, was discharged from Spectrum Health Butterworth Hospital on Tuesday.

Both were victims of Cunningham's husband, Bart Cunningham, 37, a former state trooper who had pleaded guilty to a sex crime in 2003. Bart Cunningham took his own life during the shooting.

Ionia Department of Public Safety has not released details of what led to the shooting.