Thursday, April 1, 2021

04012021 - Detroit PD Sergeant Elaine Williams Murder Case - Judge Lawrence Talon Granted Eddie Ray-Jr. Johnson Bond

 




"The Wayne County Prosecutor said Johnson shot Williams five times in front of her 12-year-old son in 2019 in their Garden City home."






Detroit PD Sergeant Elaine Williams Murder Case Posts:


























Man accused of murdering police officer released on $10K bond for medical procedure
MLive
Apr. 02, 2021
DETROIT – A man who was being held in jail pending trial for the murder of a Detroit Police officer has been released on a $10,000 bond with a tether for a medical procedure, FOX 2 Detroit reports.

Eddie Ray Johnson is charged with first-degree murder in the 2019 death of 35-year-old Elaine Williams, a 14-year member of the Detroit Police Department and mother of two, the TV station reports. Williams and Johnson were in a relationship and lived together at the time of Williams’ death.

It is alleged that, in June 2019, Johnson shot Williams in the head at close range four times and once in the shoulder before shooting and wounding himself at their home in Garden City, the report said.

Johnson claims that he acted in self-defense. The bond granted by a Wayne County judge allows Johnson to stay out of jail until his trial, which could be in about a year, the report said.

Friends and family of Williams’ told FOX 2 they believe Johnson is a flight risk and a danger to the community. The Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office called the bond amount “ridiculously low” for a first-degree murder case.



















Detroit Police Chief Craig blasts decision granting bond to man charged with killing DPD sergeant
Click On Detroit - WDIV
April 05, 2021

















Garden City man charged with murder of Detroit officer granted bond
Kym Worthy, James Craig voice opposition to judge’s decision
Click On Detroit - WDIV
April 05, 2021

"This is a ridiculously low bond for a first-degree murder case. It was inappropriate, and the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office will be appealing the court’s bond decision."
Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy


WAYNE COUNTY, Mich. – A Garden City man charged in the shooting death of his domestic partner, a Detroit police officer, was granted bond.

Eddie Ray-Jr. Johnson is accused of killing Elaine Williams in their home in Garden City on June 2, 2019. Police said he shot Williams multiple times.

Officers arrived at the home in the 200 block of Belton Street at 11:45 p.m. and found Williams dead inside. Johnson was charged with first-degree murder and felony firearm

On Thursday, Judge Lawrence Talon reduced Johnson’s bond from remand status to a $100,000/10% bond with a GPS tether and house arrest for a medical procedure.

“Her life was worth more than any bail amount and definitely more than $10,000,” Williams’ sister Keisha Kemble said.

Detroit police chief James Craig said he wants to know why a man accused of murdering a police officer in an act of domestic violence was given such a low bond.

“I wish that judge explained to this family and DPD family why that was done. Please let us know,” Craig said.

















Worthy to appeal after court gives $10K bond to man charged in 2019 Garden City murder
FOX 2 News - Detroit
April 5, 2021







GARDEN CITY, Mich. (FOX 2) - Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy said she plans to appeal the bond decision after a man charged with killing a Detroit police officer was released from jail.

Eddie Ray Johnson is charged with first-degree murder in connection with the 2019 murder of Elaine Williams at their Garden City home.

Johnson was given a $100,000/10% bond with a GPS tether and house arrest for a medical procedure after his bond was reduced last week.

Judge Lawrence Talon issued the bond. If he posts bond, Johnson will stay out until the trial, which could be nearly a year from now.

"A compassionate release? Where is the compassion for her family, where's the compassion for her children?" said pastor Maurice Hardwick, a community activist.

Johnson is accused of shooting Williams multiple times before shooting and injuring himself at their home on Belton Street on June 2, 2019.

"She was shot five times. Tragically, one of her sons remained in the home when this incident occurred," Detroit police Chief James Craig said. 

Williams, a sergeant with the Detroit Police Department, was a 14-year veteran of the force when she was killed at 35. She had a son with Johnson.

"I live in Detroit, the county of Wayne, and I am disgusted," said Detroit police Sgt. Mark Young.

Williams' family and Detroit police officials are angry at the decision to let Johnson out on bail.

"Her life was worth more than any bail amount and certainly worth more than $10,000," her said Keisha Kemble said. "Our hearts are forever broke and this decision has opened a wound that will not heal."

The community is calling on the judge to reconsider the bond.

"This is a ridiculously low bond for a first-degree murder case. It was inappropriate, and the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office will be appealing the court’s bond decision," Worthy said.

Talon did not return Fox 2's calls seeking comment, and Johnson's defense attorney declined to comment.


















Slain cop's sister 'horrified' at accused killer's release on bond
The Detroit News
April 05, 2021




Detroit — The sister of slain Detroit Police Sgt. Elaine Williams expressed outrage Monday after the man accused of killing Williams two years ago in an alleged domestic violence shooting was released on bond last week.

During a press conference in Detroit Public Safety Headquarters, Detroit police officials echoed the criticism of Wayne County Circuit Judge Lawrence Talon's decision to release murder suspect Eddie Ray-Jr. Johnson on a tether.

Williams, a mother of two and a 14-year Detroit police veteran who worked in the Major Crimes Section, was killed June 2, 2019, in the Garden City home she shared with her domestic partner, Johnson.

Williams' 12-year-old son was home during the incident, in which she was shot five times, although Johnson reportedly removed his biological son from the home prior to the shooting.

Johnson, 35, was arrested and charged last year with first-degree murder and felony firearm. Like most first-degree murder defendants, he was remanded to the Wayne County Jail to await trial.

But on Thursday, Talon reduced the defendant’s bond from remand status to a $100,000/10% bond with a GPS tether and house arrest. 

Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy released a statement Monday calling it "a ridiculously low bond for a first-degree murder case. It was inappropriate, and the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office will be appealing the court’s bond decision.” 

Keisha Kemble, the victim's sister, said during Monday's press briefing that she and her family are "horrified by the judge's decision."

Kemble's voice cracked as she addressed the press with her and Williams' father, Roy Binon, at her side. He did not speak to reporters.

"Her life was worth more than any bail amount," Kemble said. "Our hearts are forever broken, and this decision has opened up a wound that hasn't healed.

"I hope and pray that the judge would change his ruling and keep him where he belongs for killing my sister," she said. "He didn't have to look at my 5-year-old nephew and tell him his mother was dead, and watch the tears roll out of his eyes."

Neither Talon nor Johnson's attorney Ray Burkett returned phone calls seeking comment Monday, although police Chief James Craig said Johnson's release was for an unspecified medical condition. 

"I'm told (Johnson) was being treated medically in the Wayne County Jail, but whatever the reasons were, if that individual needed to be released for some higher-level care, that should be done — as long as he's taken right back to jail," the chief said.

"A compassionate release for medical reasons, then directed him home on GPS tether? Unreal," Craig said. "I’ve been doing this job a long time. … I don’t recall a time when a murder suspect, a defendant awaiting trial, was released on a tether."

Johnson's release comes as Wayne County court officials are weighing bond reform and other changes, following a lawsuit filed last year by the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan against 36th District Court magistrates.

The lawsuit claims the cash bail system is unconstitutional and discriminates against poor people "by locking them up because they cannot afford to pay while allowing those who have money to go free."

Craig said he supports bail reform for misdemeanors and some nonviolent felonies, "but never for people with histories of violence. It's so annoying, and there's no real accountability."

Craig and other law enforcement officials have long complained about allegedly violent criminals being released with no or low bond, although the chief said Monday a minority of judges and magistrates are making those decisions. 

Last month, two suspects were freed from jail without having to post bond after they allegedly pointed a gun at Detroit officers before leading them on a high-speed chase that ended when the car plowed into a police cruiser.

"This is a conversation that we’re having weekly, when we talk about crime and suspects being released into our community who have a history of violence," Craig said. "When will it stop?"

Detroit police Lt. Donna McCord, who worked with Williams, said during Monday's press conference that she and her co-workers were "offended" at the judge's decision.

"Elaine was an advocate for those who couldn’t advocate for themselves," she said. "Did the judge take into account the emotional effects of his decision on Elaine's sons? What message does it send to other victims who are already afraid to come forward?"

Pastor Maurice Hardwick of Power Ministries Church, who is known as "Pastor Mo," called Williams "a lively, bright spirit."

"I met her in the field; she worked with misguided youth. ...  She was the one who defends and protects others," he said. "Who protects her? I'm upset today. A compassionate release? Well, where is the compassion for her family? Where the compassion for her children? Where is it?"


















Judge grants man charged with murdering Detroit cop $10K bond, tether for medical procedure
FOX 2 Detroit
April 6, 2021







FOX 2 - The family of the murdered Detroit police officer found out Friday that the person accused of killing her could be let out on a $10,000 bond and a tether. They are terrified about what he could do next.

A judge granted the suspect, Eddie Ray Johnson, to get out of jail for a medical procedure - and stay out until the trial which could be nearly a year from now. However, Johnson is still in police custody and has not bonded out. 

"My heart just dropped hurt so bad everybody hurting right now," said Christine Begoski. "I just felt like the system has let us down." 

Christine Begoske is holding her grandchildren close after learning the man accused of killing her daughter, 35-year-old Detroit Police Officer Elaine Williams is free.

"He doesn't need to be out that long," she said. "Let him get his little procedure done and go back to jail. He doesn't need to be out until January, that is a long time. My daughter doesn't get to see any sunshine, I don't get to see her at all."

"For him to be out on a tether, one thing I can say, I worked for the Department of Corrections - I worked for the absconder recovery unit," said family friend Bo Grimm. "I know in two seconds that tether can be cut and he's gone. He could be in Jamaica by tomorrow."

In June 2019, while in their Belton Street home in Garden City, Johnson is accused of shooting Elaine four times in the head at close range and once in the shoulder, before he allegedly shot and wounded himself.

Johnson claims he killed his girlfriend, who was a well-respected 14-year veteran of the Detroit Police Department, in self-defense.

But her best friend from childhood, Bo Grimm, says that is nonsense. Just days before, Elaine told her she was leaving him for good.
 
And knowing the couple's history of domestic abuse, Grimm said he fears what he could do next.

"He's a flight risk, a community risk, and the justice system has definitely let us down," he said. "He's going to hurt somebody else and I hope the judge can live with that." 

The Wayne County Prosecutor's Office isn't happy with the judge's decision which tried to argue against the reduction of bond in a statement it called "A ridiculously low amount." 

Prosecutor Kym Worthy added, "This is a first-degree murder case. I think the court's bond ruling is completely inappropriate."

"She didn't deserve what she got," Grimm said. "She has two kids that can never see their mother again. They don't deal with this (just) when it happened, they have to deal with it the rest of their lives."
   
"Him coming here and taking my grandson and him running away and getting away with murder - that's my biggest concern," said Begoske. "And I am scared for my grandsons. They were in the house when she was murdered."

Worthy added that the Wayne County Sheriff's Department said it will be closely monitoring the defendant's GPS tether if he is out on bond.

















Prosecutor to appeal release of man accused of murdering Michigan police sergeant
MLive
Apr. 06, 2021
GARDEN CITY, MI – A Michigan prosecutor plans to appeal a judge’s decision to release a man accused of murdering a Detroit Police sergeant in 2019.

Eddie Ray Johnson was being held in jail pending trial for first-degree murder until a judge released him on bond last week. On Thursday, April 1, Wayne Circuit Court Judge Lawrence Talon granted Johnson a $100,000/10% bond with a tether and house arrest for a medical procedure. He will be out of jail until his trial, which could be in about a year.

Wayne County Prosecutor Kim Worthy told FOX 2 Detroit that she plans to appeal the release. She previously called the bond amount “ridiculously low” for a first-degree murder case.

Johnson is accused in the 2019 death of 35-year-old Elaine Williams, a sergeant and 14-year member of the Detroit Police Department and mother of two. Williams and Johnson were in a relationship and lived together at the time of Williams’ death; they also have a child together.

It is alleged that, in June 2019, Johnson shot Williams in the head at close range four times and once in the shoulder before shooting and wounding himself at their home in Garden City. Johnson claims that he acted in self-defense.
















National Association Of Police Organizations, Inc.
Letter To: Chief Judge Timothy M. Kenny, Third Judicial Circuit Court of Michigan
RE: Release of Eddie Ray Johnson Jr. charged with murder of Detroit Sergeant Elaine Williams
https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/20604462/napo-letter_accountability-for-judge-talon.pdf
NAPO















Prayer vigil honors Detroit Sgt. Elaine Williams as accused killer is freed on bond
Click On Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV
Apr 9, 2021
















The Detroit Police Department conducting a prayer vigil for Sergeant Elaine Williams
Detroit Police Department
Apr 9, 2021



"It's only one word to describe when people hide, it's called cowardly"
Said @ChiefJECraig as members of the Detroit Police Department and the community expressed their anger towards the charging decision made by Judge Talon regarding a murder defendant.
#JusticeForElaine
#EndDomesticViolence














Prayer vigil held to honor slain Detroit police sergeant after accused killer released on bond
Click On Detroit - WDIV
April 09, 2021
DETROIT – Friends, family and Detroit police gathered on Friday to remember slain Sgt. Elaine Williams after bond was reduced for her accused killer

“It’s always difficult to say goodbye. But I think that we will never, never forget Elaine. Never,” Detroit police Chief James Craig said.

Williams was shot and killed in her Garden City home on June 2, 2019. Police said she was shot multiple times.

Her domestic partner, Eddie Ray-Jr. Johnson is accused of killing her. Johnson is facing a first-degree murder charge and a felony firearm charge.

On Thursday, Judge Lawrence Talon reduced Johnson’s bond from remand status to a $100,000/10% bond with a GPS tether and house arrest for a medical procedure.

Williams’ friends and family said they were appalled that Talon reduced Johnson’s bond.

“Her life was worth more than any bail amount and definitely more than $10,000,” Williams’ sister Keisha Kemble said.

Craig said he wants to know why a man accused of murdering a police officer in an act of domestic violence was given such a low bond.

“I wish that judge explained to this family and DPD family why that was done. Please let us know,” Craig said.















Justice For DPD Sgt. Elaine Williams prayer vigil at DPD HQ
The Detroit News
Apr. 9, 2021




































Chief Craig calls judge a coward for compassionate release of accused cop killer
FOX 2 Detroit
April 9, 2021


Accused cop killer gets compassionate release by judge until trial, sparking outrage Judge Lawrence Talon allowed the release of a suspected murderer of a 14-year police veteran on $10,000 bond and a tether.






FOX 2 - Friends, colleagues, and family of the late Detroit Police Sgt. Elaine Williams rallied Friday to criticize the judge who allowed the suspect charged with her murder, to be released on a tether to have a medical procedure. 

Judge Lawrence Talon also set a bond of $10,000 and is letting the accused murderer, Eddie Ray Johnson, stay out on bond until his trial date.

"We are appalled that Judge Talon allowed the defendant who murdered Elaine to bond out on a measly $10,000," said Joanna Ali Johnson, retired Detroit police sergeant. "We prayed that the judge will resend his decision and bring the defendant back where he belongs locked up."

Sgt. Williams was a 14-year veteran of Detroit police at the time she was killed allegedly by her boyfriend Eddie Ray Johnson, who claimed the shooting was in self-defense. 

Documents confirm that Johnson is out on bond with an electronic monitoring unit. 

"We talk about $10,000, this suspect got out for nothing. He's on a tether facing murder," said Detroit Police Chief James Craig.

Detroit's police chief is just one of the many speakers calling for the judge to do the right thing. 

"This despicable action of the judge. Shameful," Craig said. "And I hope he's watching. There's one way to describe when people hide -  it's called cowardly." 

"We know it's not enough Wayne County sheriffs to monitor defendants on tether," said Assistant Police Chief Todd Bettison, Detroit Police Department.

A recording of a message Sgt Williams gave to students was played during Friday's call for action.

Her family said they are praying that this community support will help the judge see he is not delivering justice  

"We all should all be concerned," said LaKeisha Kemble, Sgt. Williams' sister. "Because if this can happen to my sister, a dedicated police sergeant, this injustice can happen to anyone."

FOX 2 contacted Johnson's attorney who has not responded for comment. 

The prosecutor's office requested Judge Talon to reconsider the reduction of bond and he declined.. The prosecutor's office says it is going to appeal that decision. 

"He is held accountable by this community," Craig said. "He sits in that seat because of the community."















Craig at vigil for slain cop: Judge in bond decision 'cowardly'
The Detroit News
April 09, 2021












Detroit — Friends, relatives and former co-workers of slain Detroit Police Sgt. Elaine Williams minced no words Friday in castigating the judge who granted bond to her alleged killer.

"There's one word for people who hide. It's called cowardly," Detroit police chief James Craig said during a vigil for Williams, a mother of two and a 14-year Detroit police veteran who was killed June 2, 2019, in the Garden City home she shared with her domestic partner, Eddie Ray-Jr. Johnson.

Johnson was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. Wayne County Circuit Judge Lawrence Talon on April 1 ordered the defendant released on a tether because of an undisclosed medical condition, reducing the defendant’s bond from remand status to a $100,000/10% bond.

The judge's decision was roundly panned Monday during a press conference at Detroit Public Safety Headquarters — a theme that continued during Friday's prayer vigil outside headquarters, as several speakers called the judge a coward and implored him to rescind his decision.

"The purpose today is to demand justice for Elaine, and to hopefully send a powerful message to Judge Talon and other judges," said mistress of ceremony Joanna Ali-Johnson, an ex-Detroit cop and civilian employee of the department.

Williams' attorney Raymond Burkett did not return phone calls seeking comment, while Talon said via email he couldn't talk about about his decision while the case is active.

"Because this is a pending case I cannot discuss it at this time. It would not be fair to those involved," the judge said.

Craig said during Friday's vigil: "We're public servants. We don't get to hide. This is so much disrespect."

Williams' sister LaKeisha Kemble said the criminal justice system failed her sister.

"I hope everyone listening will feel outrage," she said. "Not just because she was my sister, or because she was a police officer. But because she was a human being."

Kemble cried while reading a passage from the Bible's Book of Revelations: "He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away."

Assistant Police Chief Todd Bettison said he wants Talon to reverse his decision to grant bail to Johnson.

"Eddie is sitting at home chilling right now," he said. "I want him locked up. I want the judge to reconsider."

Annie Holt, vice chair of the Detroit Board of Police Commissioners, said she supports the current efforts to revamp the cash bail system, which she and other advocates say unfairly punishes the poor.

"Most of us support bail reform because we saw how the courts criminalize poor people," Holt said. "But most of us do not want reform that sends violent offenders back into the community."

Capt. Keeth Williams, who was Elaine Williams' friend but not related, said: "I am very, very angry at this judge. But I'm more angry at the system, because the system has failed Elaine.

"This man Eddie is a coward, and there's nothing stopping him from running," he said. "It's an insult to every one of you, to every one of us for that man to be out on a tether."

Williams added Talon's decision sends a poor message to domestic violence victims.

"If you can't make a better decision than this, then you should not be sitting on the stand," he said. "This sends a message to all other victims of domestic violence that we can let the coward who did this to you go free."

A video was played during Friday's ceremony showing Elaine Williams mentoring Detroit high school students.

"We must respect each other, your parents, and yourself," Captain Williams said. "You never know what one smile, one hug can do for someone."

Ali-Johnson asked the crowd to chant "Justice for Elaine" five times to represent the five times she was shot.

"Let's hope and pray Judge Talon hears us," she said.

Following Friday's vigil, about 20 people protested outside Wayne County Circuit Court at Frank Murphy Hall of Justice, chanting "Lock him back up" and "Justice for Elaine."

"We're here to send a message to the judge," said Teesha Bess, Elaine Williams' cousin. "The judge put $10,000 on her life. Her life is worth more than $10,000."















Family protests judge's decision to grant bond to man charged with killing Detroit police sergeant
Click On Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV
Apr 15, 2021

















Family protests judge’s decision granting bond to man charged with killing Detroit police sergeant
Sgt. Elaine Williams was shot and killed in 2019
Click On Detroit - WDIV
April 15, 2021
LIVONIA, Mich. – Friends and family of Detroit police Sgt. Elaine Williams protested in front of Wayne County Judge Lawrence Talon’s Livonia home for more than an hour Thursday.

Carrying signs and wearing commemorative t-shirts, they repeatedly shouted “Justice for Elaine.”

Williams was shot dead by her boyfriend in 2019. The suspect, Eddie Ray Johnson, claimed it was self defense.

Johnson’s trial is pending and he needs a medical procedure. Talon granted him a compassionate release and ordered him to pay a $10,000 bond, wear a tether and he can remain at home after medical treatment.

Both Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy and Detroit Police Chief James Craig said the bond is inappropriate. Worthy’s office is appealing the decision.

“Judge Talon let her murderer free on a temporary bond. That’s $2,000 for every time he shot her. This is just not right,” said Williams’ childhood friend, Marquise Mitchell















Judge affirms bond for alleged Detroit cop-killer
The Detroit News
April 23, 2021






Detroit — A Wayne County judge denied prosecutors' request Friday to reverse his decision earlier this month to grant bond to a man accused of killing a Detroit police officer, saying the defendant is not a flight risk or danger to society.

Judge Lawrence Talon's April 1 ruling in the case of Eddie Ray-Jr. Johnson prompted protests and sharp criticism from Detroit police; Johnson is charged with first-degree murder in connection with the June 2, 2019, shooting death of Detroit police Sgt. Elaine Williams, his domestic partner.

Talon's April 1 ruling ordered the defendant released on a tether because of an undisclosed medical condition, reducing the defendant’s bond from remand status to a $100,000/10% bond. Police chief James Craig and other officers called the judge's decision "cowardly."

Following a nearly two-hour hearing Friday in Wayne County Circuit Court, the judge denied a motion from Wayne County prosecutors asking him to increase Johnson's bond to $250,000 with no 10% provision.

Assistant Wayne County Prosecutor Maria Miller said in an email Friday: "A decision will be made about appealing the judge’s ruling in the near future."

After Talon rendered his decision to uphold Johnson's bond conditions, the judge said Craig's "personal attack" against him was a "threat to democracy."

Talon said since he granted Johnson's release from jail, protesters have been picketing outside the Wayne Circuit courthouse in Detroit, and outside his Livonia home. He said someone put a picture of Williams and a letter in his mailbox Friday morning imploring him to change his bond decision.

The judge said someone also sent him text messages about the case, including a link  to an April 9 Detroit News story bearing the headline: "Craig at vigil for slain cop: Judge in bond decision 'cowardly.'" 

"I'm not supposed to read about the case, but you couldn't miss it," Talon said. "Right in the headline, it says my decision was cowardly.

"I believe public officials have the constitutional right to call other public officials cowardly ... but I also believe when government officials make personal attacks on judges, that it’s a threat to the independence of the judiciary, and as such it’s a threat to democracy," the judge said.

Craig responded: "I don't deny what I said. I said it on the record because that's what I felt about him. I'm deeply disappointed in his decision."

Mark Young, president of the Detroit Police Lieutenants and Sergeants Association union, who has been picketing outside the judge's house, said after Friday's hearing that the demonstrations will continue in light of Talon's decision.

"I'm just speechless," he said. "This is injustice. What message does this send to domestic violence victims? What message does this send to law enforcement?"

Talon cited several factors that prompted his decision to deny the prosecution's request to increase Johnson's bond, including evidence that suggests Williams shot Johnson first.

"Based on the Medical Examiner's testimony and the state police report, a reasonable conclusion is that the defendant was shot first," the judge said. "He claims Ms. Williams shot him first, and that he got the gun and shot her."

Talon said jurors could find Johnson guilty of crimes ranging from first-degree murder to manslaughter. "I'm not saying those will be the verdicts," he said. "I'm just saying when you look at the likelihood of conviction, they could come up with any number of possible verdicts."

Craig replied: "It sounds like (Talon) is setting up a self-defense claim for (Johnson)."

Williams was a mother of two and a 14-year Detroit police veteran who worked in the Major Crimes Section. Her 12-year-old son was home when she was shot five times, although Johnson reportedly removed his biological son from the home before the shooting.

During his arraignment a week after the killing, Johnson was ordered remanded to the Wayne County Jail. The charges were lowered to second-degree murder following Johnson's two-day preliminary examination, although Talon later reinstated the first-degree murder charge.

"Domestic violence is a terrible thing," Talon said. "But but not all violence between domestic partners means the person accused of the domestic violence is a danger to the public. They are often a danger to the other partner."

Talon said he doesn't take the protests against him personally.

"Based on the Judicial Code of Conduct, I cannot talk to you," he said to the demonstrators. "I cannot come outside. I cannot read your signs or listen to the chants, and I cannot look at the picture of Elaine Williams and the letter that was left in my mailbox this morning.

"In every case that comes before the court, when the court makes a decision, one side is going to be unhappy," Talon said. "No judge is insensitive to the pain and grief we've seen on both sides of the aisle.

"But it's my hope that, even if you disagree with my decision, I hope and trust that you'll feel you received a fair hearing. The defendant is presumed innocent."



Saturday, February 20, 2021

02202021 - Detroit PD Lt. Willie F. Duncan - Sexual Assault Of First Victim - Charged With Third Degree CSC [08202021]

 












Detroit police identify 128 'high risk' officers following 7 Investigation
'I haven't found any other police agency that's being this proactive,' Chief says
WXYZ News - Detroit
March 24, 2022


DETROIT (WXYZ) — The Detroit Police Department has identified 128 officers on the force today as “high risk,” promising to retrain or reign in officers with concerning behavior trends.

The announcement comes as a result of a series of 7 Action News investigations that revealed officers sued as many as a dozen of times, some charged repeatedly by prosecutors or accused over and over of using racist language and excessive force.

“Overwhelmingly, the officers in this department do what they’re supposed to do,” said Chief James White, who created the new risk management unit. “And when you have an outlier, I think it’s equally important to hold those officers accountable.”

White ordered the top to bottom review of the entire 2,600 member police force late last year. The department-wide assessment is not just a one-off, but a new way to continually monitor officers’ risky behavior going forward, White says.

Following earlier reports by 7 Action News, the department acknowledged that its Management Awareness System, or MAS, had been using since 2008 to monitor officer misconduct was out of date, missing red flags that allowed too many problem cops to slip through the cracks.

Asst. Chief David LeValley says the MAS system flagged an officer only if he or she racked up repeated misconduct in a short period of time, but it too often missed bad behavior that was stretched out over years, or longer.

Under the new risk management unit, each officer is given a “risk score” generated by their number of citizen complaints, discipline, how often they use force, are involved in vehicle chases and vehicle accidents over the span of their career.

“It gives us a real time picture as to the risk activities that they’re engaging in right now,” LeValley said.

What the department found is that 128 officers on the street today—or 5% of the force—are considered “high risk.”

Most have been on the force for five years or less and a numbe, the department says, were trained or supervised by officers with their own troubled histories.

Two of the supervisors include Lieutenant Willie Duncan, who just last year was charged with criminal sexual conduct, and Sgt. William Zeolla, who leads the department in complaints and has been sued at least 12 times.

“What is alarming is the rate at which some of these officers over the last two years are generating these activities compared to the rest of the department,” LeValley said.

The goal of the new system is to flag early warning signs in an officer’s behavior before bad conduct becomes ingrained.

Last week, 7 Action News revealed how two Detroit officers conducted an improper police chase that ended in a young woman’s death.

Officers deliberately kept their lights and sirens off and attempted to keep their dash camera off too in what a sergeant said amounted to a cover-up.

You’ll find both officers on the “high risk” list for conduct that happened before that improper chase. They’re each now awaiting discipline that could include termination.

“We’ve made some assignment changes based on risk,” Chief White said. “We’re going to be creating some individualized training opportunities for people that have hit our risk score and we’re also going to be preventing some assignments.”

DPD officials plan to change risky behavior through a months-long monitoring period. Each officer on the list will meet at headquarters with an assistant chief or the chief himself, instructed on how their conduct needs to change.

A sergeant will accompany the officers on runs, their body camera footage will be randomly checked and they’ll go through intensive retraining, if needed.

If the officer shows a pattern of targeting certain groups, like people of color, they’ll meet with Mary Engelman, DPD’s new Director of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion.

“The work is tough,” Engelman said. “Because you’re dealing with people and you’re dealing with cultures and you’re dealing with biases.”

The goal, says Asst. Chief LeValley, is not to fire officers but to change their behavior.

“At some point I’m sure some officer that participate in this process aren’t going to change, and we’ll take the appropriate steps at that time,” he said.

It’s early, but Detroit Police Commissioner Ricardo Moore say he’s optimistic the new system will shine a light on Detroit’s troubled cops.

“If you have a police chief who sides with the police and believes in the blue culture, so to speak, things will slide through the cracks,” Moore said.

“I believe our current police chief, James White, is not that person.”


















Detroit cop charged with sexually assaulting fellow officer, 2nd alleged victim comes forward
MLive
Aug. 23, 2021



DETROIT -- A lieutenant with the Detroit Police Department has been charged with third-degree criminal sexual conduct after he allegedly assaulted a fellow officer following a party in February. According to WXYZ Detroit, Lt. Willie F. Duncan, 47, was arraigned on the charge Friday in 36th District Court.

Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy’s office worked with the Detroit Police Department to investigate Duncan after a 39-year-old female officer with the department alleged she was assaulted by Duncan after she returned home from a party at 3 a.m. on February 20.

“The allegation against the lieutenant, to say troubling is an understatement,” said Interim Police Chief James White during a press conference Friday.

Along with the charges issued Friday, another alleged victim has come forward, according to police. That case involves an alleged assault that took place in May. Police are continuing to investigate those accusations as well.

Duncan is expected to be back in court on Aug. 27 for a probable cause conference.
















DPD lieutenant charged in connection to alleged sex assault of an officer
WXYZ News - Detroit
August 20, 2021


DPD lieutenant charged in connection to alleged sex assault of an officer
















Veteran Detroit police officer charged with criminal sexual conduct
Willie Duncan accused of forcibly engaging in sex with woman in her home
Click On Detroit
August 20, 2021



DETROIT – A 20-year veteran officer of the Detroit Police Department is accused of forcibly engaging in sex with a woman against her will inside her home.

Lt. Willie Duncan is charged with criminal sexual conduct in the third degree -- force or coercion. A not guilty plea was entered on his behalf Friday during a 36th District Court hearing.

The judge said there is a “very extensive” investigative report on the allegations against Duncan, calling them “troubling at best.”

“Mr. Duncan allegedly did enter the complainant’s home and forcibly engaged in sex with her against her will,” the judge said.

The Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office (WCPO) said the incident happened about 3 a.m. Feb. 20, 2021.

“The complainant returned home from a party and Lt. Duncan appeared at her door. When she opened her door he came inside the home. Once inside it is alleged that he sexually assaulted her,” reads a statement from the prosecutor’s office.

A warrant request was handed to WCPO on July 22.

Duncan’s attorney said he is on suspension amid an internal affairs investigation at the police department. The judge originally set bond at $35,000, or 10%, but then agreed to $25,000, or 10%. His attorney had asked for $20,000, or 10%.

Duncan also is ordered not to have contact with the victim.

A probable cause conference is scheduled for Aug. 27.














DPD lieutenant charged in connection to alleged sex assault of an officer
WXYZ News - Detroit
August 20, 2021



DPD lieutenant charged in connection to alleged sex assault of an officer
















Detroit Police Department lieutenant charged with criminal sexual conduct
Click On Detroit - WDIV
Aug 20, 2021



A 20-year veteran officer of the Detroit Police Department is accused of forcibly engaging in sex with a woman against her will inside her home.
















Detroit police lieutenant accused of sexually assaulting other officers
FOX 2 News - Detroit
Aug 20, 2021



A Detroit police lieutenant is facing charges in connection with the alleged sexual assault of an officer and is accused of another sexual assault.















Detroit Police Department lieutenant charged after alleged sex assault of police officer
Detroit Free Press
August 20, 2021




Lt. Willie Duncan of the Detroit Police Department was charged with third-degree criminal sexual conduct in the alleged sexual assault of a 39-year-old police officer in February.

According to a news release from the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office, Duncan, 47, allegedly went to the officer’s house at 3 a.m. Feb. 20, after she returned from a party. When the officer opened the door, prosecutors say Duncan came in and sexually assaulted her.

On July 22, the prosecutor’s office received a warrant request. Duncan was arraigned Friday in 36th District Court and got a $25,000 10% bond, with a condition that he have no contact with the officer he allegedly assaulted, according to the news release. Duncan’s probable cause conference will be held Aug. 27, before Judge Kenyetta Stanford Jones.

Duncan also was accused of sexually assaulting another police officer on May 21 at an off-duty social gathering attended by members of the department. The alleged assault was reported to former Police Chief James Craig on May 28, prompting an immediate investigation by Internal Affairs. The next day, Duncan was reassigned to another unit within the police department as the investigation continued.

After learning additional facts provided by Internal Affairs, Interim Police Chief James White suspended Duncan with pay on June 8. Several days later, allegations of the February assault were reported to Internal Affairs. 

Although it was reported before the February incident, prosecutors have not charged Duncan for the alleged incident that occurred in May, though the investigation is still in progress.

"Wearing this badge is an absolute privilege. It is not a right," White said Friday during a news conference. "It is a privilege to be a Detroit police officer and, if your conduct does not support that privilege of being able to represent this department and this city with this badge, it is my responsibility to ensure that you don't wear one." 

















Detroit police lieutenant charged with sexually assaulting another DPD officer
FOX 2 - Detroit
August 20, 2021


DETROIT - A Detroit police lieutenant has been charged with criminal sexual conduct in the third degree following accusations he raped a female officer last February.

The charge against Lt. Willie Fred Duncan was filed Aug. 18. He was arraigned in the 36th District Court Friday morning. 

Duncan, who has served more than 20 years with the Detroit Police Department according to his attorney, entered a not guilty plea Friday. 

A judge reading from a report that alleged that Duncan had entered a complainant's home and forced sex against her will described the details as "troubling at best."

According to a release from the Wayne County Prosecutor's Office, the female victim returned home from a party Feb. 20 when Duncan appeared at her door. When she opened the door, he came inside where he allegedly sexually assaulted her. 

Duncan's attorney said during the arraignment that the officer has been suspended and confirmed he's been in contact with the internal affairs bureau. 

Judge Kenyetta Stanford Jones ordered Duncan to avoid all contact with the victim. He also set his bond at $25,000/10% and set the next court date for Aug. 27. 

According to Detroit police, the sexual assault allegation was brought forward while they were investigating a different incident. Police said that on May 28, a report was made to then-Chief James Craig that Duncan had allegedly sexually assaulted an officer at an off-duty social gathering a week prior.

Duncan was moved to a different unit pending an investigation. On June 8, Chief James White, who assumed the role of chief in early June, suspended Duncan with pay. After that, the February incident was brought to DPD's attention.

After an internal investigation, warrant packets for both alleged incidents were submitted to the Wayne County Prosecutor's Office on June 22. On Wednesday, the office signed the warrant request for the February incident. No charges have been issued for the May alleged assault.

White has requested permission from the police board of commissioners to suspend Duncan without pay.

"It is a privilege to be a Detroit police officer," White said. "If your conduct does not support that privilege of being able to represent this department in this city with this badge, it is my responsibility to ensure that you don't wear one."

Duncan is reportedly out of custody after making bond Friday.

In response to a request for comment, defense attorney Sam Bennett said: "Mr. Duncan maintains his innocence. He was incredibly shocked by the allegations. He does know this woman but nothing described in the allegations occurred."
















DPD lieutenant charged in connection to alleged sex assault of an officer
WXYZ News - Detroit
August 20, 2021
(WXYZ) — A Detroit Police Department lieutenant was arraigned today on sexual assault charges in 36th District Court, according to the Wayne County Prosecutor’s office.

The prosecutor’s office said Detroit Police Lt. Willie F. Duncan, 47, allegedly sexually assaulted a 39-year-old female DPD officer when she returned home from a party on February 20 at 3 a.m.

Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy today charged Lt. Duncan with Criminal Sexual Conduct Third Degree, a felony with a maximum penalty of 15 years in prison.

The Detroit Police Department at a press conference Friday said they have been working closely with the Wayne County Prosecutor's office and that another alleged victim, an employee of the department, had come forward after a May incident. Police officials said the criminal and departmental investigations into that May incident continue, and the outcome should be announced in the near future.

Interim Detroit Police Chief James White said he has asked that the lieutenant be suspended without pay.

“These allegations obviously are severe and we do not take them lightly," said Chief White.

Duncan's probable cause conference is scheduled for August 27.
















Detroit lieutenant suspended, charged with sexual assault
The Detroit News
August 20, 2021



A Detroit police lieutenant on Friday was arraigned on sexual assault charges and suspended from the force without pay, authorities said. 

Lt. Willie F. Duncan, 47, was charged by Wayne County Prosecutor Kym L. Worthy in connection with the alleged sexual assault of a 39-year-old female DPD officer, the prosecutor's office announced in a press release Friday. 

Chris Graveline, director of the Detroit Police Professional Standards Section said at an afternoon press conference that Duncan, a 26-year veteran of the department, was arraigned Friday on one count of third-degree criminal sexual conduct on allegations of "force or coercion to commit rape," a felony that can carry a sentence of up to 15 years in prison. 

Previously, Duncan had been suspended with pay after initially being reassigned from his unit. 

The court ordered a $25,000/10% bond for Duncan, with a condition that he have no contact with the survivor.  

Detroit police on Friday noted Friday that two employees of the department have come forward with allegations involving Duncan. 

The first employee reported to former police chief James Craig on May 28 that Duncan had assaulted her at an off-duty social gathering a week prior, on May 21, said Graveline. 

Craig, in his last week as police chief, alerted the force's office of internal affairs which triggered two investigations, departmental and criminal. He assigned Duncan out of his unit, but Duncan opted to use leave days and didn't report to work before the then-incoming interim police Chief James White decided to suspend him with pay on June 8. 

Five days later, on June 13, the second allegation involving the 39-year-old officer surfaced. The woman claimed Duncan had assaulted her in her home on Feb. 20. Her claim led to the charges. 

White said the May 21 incident was still under investigation, and could result in additional criminal charges for Duncan. 

"If your conduct does not support the privilege of being able to represent this department in this city with this badge, it is my responsibility to ensure that you don't wear one," said White.

Duncan's attorney Sam Bennett told The Detroit News Friday that his client maintains his innocence.

"Even though he knows this woman, he denies any of these allegations and that any of these incidents ever occurred," Bennett said. 

This is the second high-profile incident of alleged police misconduct this month for the department. 

On Aug. 5, another officer was suspended with pay pending an investigation into a video that surfaced on social media in which he appears to be punching an unarmed man in Greektown on Aug. 1.

White has said that the probe into how police handled those events also included allegations that supervisors reportedly violated multiple policies at the scene.

Findings of that investigation have not yet been made public.