Thursday, March 15, 2001

03152001 - Detroit Firefighter Ardra Young - Filed Petition For Writ Of Habeas Corpus - Michigan US District Court















On February 7, 1997, Detroit Firefighter Ardra Young, who also owned a truck business, went to Bolingbrook Illinois to purchase vehicles for his business.

On the evening of February 8th, Young claimed to be ill during a business dinner. He returned to his hotel room and claimed he passed out and did not wake up until approximately 3a.m.. It was when he called home at 3 a.m. and spoke with his brother, that he learned that his ex-wife Terri and teenage son Emmanuel had been shot. He was informed that his ex-wife had died and although his son had survived, he was on life support.

Young immediately left Illinois and drove home to Detroit. At the hospital, Young ordered that his son be removed from life support. Young was allowed to sign the form to have life support disconnected for Emmanuel, who died shortly after life support was removed.

On February 9th, Firefighter Young confessed to killing his wife and teenage son. According to Young, after excusing himself from the business dinner on Saturday evening, he did not return to his room. Instead he drove to Detroit and arrived at approximately 9:30pm. From a phone booth, Young called his wife to meet him in Detroit. When his wife and son arrived, he shot and killed them both. He flattened one of the tires on his wife's car and threw the contents of her purse around to make it appear as though his wife and son were robbed and killed after their car broke down. Young then drove back to Bolingbrook Illinois.

During his confession, Young claimed to police that he had killed his family, "To be free..."

Young was convicted by a jury of two counts of first-degree murder and two counts of felony- firearm in the shooting deaths of his wife Terri and son Emmanuel.

In November 1998, Young was sentenced to concurrent terms of life imprisonment and to consecutive two-year terms for felony firearm.













1 CHARGED IN DEATHS OF WIFE, SON
South Bend Tribune (IN)
February 12, 1997 
Detroit - A former Detroit firefighter was charged with killing his wife and teen-age son.

Ardra Young, 34, was arraigned Monday on two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Terri Young, 34, and Emmanuel Young, 14.

Young arranged a meeting Saturday evening with his wife of 14 years at a park near their home in Wayne County's Redford Township, police said. Terri Young insisted that Emmanuel accompany them to the park - where Ardra Young allegedly shot them both.

Young returned to his home, washed his bloodstained clothes and drove to the home of a female acquaintance in Illinois, investigators said. He returned to Detroit early Sunday, ordering doctors at Grace Hospital to turn off his son's life-support system, police said.

Young then went to Detroit police headquarters, where investigators said he described his role in the shootings.

Young, a firefighter for seven years, resigned Monday. He is jailed without bond.













Hate letters stir Detroit Fire Dept.
Newswire - UPI (USA)
January 30, 1998 
The Detroit Fire Department is on edge while the FBI investigates hate letters that claim white firefighters are ready to kill black colleagues and their families. Fire Commissioner James Bush says he's taking the threats from an unknown group called the White Fire Fighters Association 'very, very seriously.'

However, Bush is declining comment about one letter that allegedly ties the mysterious group to the shooting deaths of a black firefighter's wife and son last year. The firefighter, Ardra Young, was later dismissed and convicted on two murder counts, for which he's now serving life in prison. The letter's claim that the killings were racially motivated to punish Young has prompted his lawyer to plan an appeal. In an interview with UPI today, Bush implied that one distraught firefighter may be responsible for the letters threatening harm to any black firefighters who harass whites. At least four letters were sent in recent weeks to fire officials and the mayor's office. Bush says, 'We're a family here and when there's a member who needs guidance we all try to help.' About two-thirds of the city's 1,400 firefighters are black. Bush says the department's blacks and whites 'have a good relationship. We work very well together.' The FBI is working with Detroit police on the investigation. There've been no arrests. ---








































January 05, 1998:
Ardra Young filed an appeal on his conviction for his wife's and son's murders. On March 14, 2000, Young's conviction was confirmed.













March 14, 2000:
Michigan Court Of Appeals Affirmed Ardra Young's conviction




















March 15, 2001
Ardra Young filed a Petition For Writ Of Habeas Corpus with the Michigan US District Court















November 14, 2004:
Michigan US District Court denied Ardra Young's Petition For Writ Of Habeas Corpus

03152001 - Councilman Clyde Cleveland - Sentenced - Detroit

Cleveland is given probation in assault
He appeals for mercy
March 30, 2001
Detroit Free Press

Detroit City Councilman Clyde Cleveland told a Wayne County judge Thursday that two years' probation for pushing his wife was too severe a punishment for a man his age. "I think two years is too long," Cleveland said. "I'm 66 years old and I doubt if I'll live much longer." Still, Wayne County Circuit Judge Karen Fort Hood stuck to Cleveland's plea agreement and sentenced him to two...









Clyde Cleveland based on what he admitted, he should step down
March 2, 2001
Detroit Free Press

When Clyde Cleveland admitted to beating his wife, he also trampled many of the values he stood up for as a civil rights activist and member of the Detroit City Council. He surrendered any claim to public leadership and should now surrender his council seat. No one but Cleveland and his wife knows exactly what happened between them on Dec. 3, but what Cleveland confessed to in a plea deal is stomach-turning stuff. At a preliminary hearing, Cleveland's wife testified that...








Councilman admits assault, gets probation
Cleveland's wife says best part of deal is mandatory counseliong
February 16, 2001
Detroit Free Press

Veteran Detroit Councilman Clyde Cleveland won't go to jail or lose his $81,000-a-year job after admitting Thursday that he assaulted his wife when he pushed her against a wall and bloodied her face. Still, his wife, Mary -- who said Cleveland kicked her down the stairs, hit her in the head with a remote control and in the face with a gun -- said she would be willing to take back the man she says has beat her for many years. "I leave the ball in my...


               






Clyde Cleveland may get plea deal to avoid a trial
February 15, 2001
Detroit News

DETROIT -- A special prosecutor planned to offer a plea bargain to Detroit Councilman Clyde Cleveland today in a bid to avoid a trial on three felony charges. "I'm prepared to negotiate a resolution to this matter on terms that make maximum sense," said Justin Ravitz, a former Recorder's Court judge who was appointed as a special prosecutor. "If we can put this to bed without a trial, I'm quite comfortable with...

Thursday, March 1, 2001

03012001 - Adrian PD Officer Jason Crawford - Charged With CSC

 




Ex-cop a suspect in felonies
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
August 24, 2001 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
ADRIAN -- An Adrian police officer being investigated for felony criminal sexual conduct quit the police department this week according to Adrian Police Chief Mike Martin.

Officer Jason Crawford resigned from the department Wednesday, Martin said. Crawford also was under scrutiny as a suspect who fled on his sport motorcycle from police in a Lenawee County Sheriff's Department case, Martin added.

"I was advised recently by the sheriff's department that they were investigating Officer Crawford as a suspect in their fleeing and eluding case involving motorcycles," Martin said.

Sheriff Larry Richardson said Wednesday that investigators had identified the second suspect in an Aug. 13 pursuit with two men riding sport motorcycles. Sheriff's deputies attempted to pull over the motorcycles after observing them driving recklessly on South Main Street near Adrian Mall.

Instead of pulling over, the motorcyclists turned west on U.S. 223 and sped off from the scene at a high rate of speed, according to the sheriff's department. One of the motorcycles, believed to have been driven by Crawford, turned east on Maumee Street while the second motorcycle continued west and turned north on Wolf Creek Highway.

Jason John Serafin, 22 was passing vehicles at the crest of a hill on Hunt Road when his motorcycle crashed head-on into an Adrian Township Police Department patrol car responding to assist sheriff's deputies.

Richardson said felony fleeing and eluding charges would be sought against the second suspect in the case, but declined Wednesday to name who the suspect was until an arrest warrant had been issued by the Lenawee County Prosecutor's office.

Crawford had been on paid administrative leave while Michigan State Police at the Adrian post investigated criminal sexual conduct allegations.

Martin said he learned about the state police investigation about four weeks ago and Crawford was placed on leave then. An internal department investigation was also being conducted when Crawford resigned, Martin said.

Crawford was hired as a patrol officer by the department in January 1998 after moving to the area from Akron, Ohio. He attended Wayne County Regional Police Academy and Adrian College.


















Crawford charged with pair of felonies
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
August 25, 2001
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
ADRIAN -- A former Adrian police officer is facing felony charges for criminal sexual conduct and fleeing and eluding police.

Jason Crawford, 27, was arrested Friday morning by police. He was arraigned Friday afternoon before Lenawee County District Court Judge Natalia Koselka on charges of first- and second-degree criminal sexual conduct and fleeing and eluding a police officer.

A cash surety bond of $150,000 was set for Crawford and he was returned to the Lenawee County Jail. Sheriff Larry Richardson said Crawford would be lodged at another county jail for security reasons until he posts bond.

A preliminary examination for Crawford is scheduled for 2 p.m. Friday in district court.

Officers from Adrian police, Lenawee County Sheriff's Department and Michigan State Police arrived at Crawford's Adrian residence Friday morning and served the warrants. Adrian Police Chief Mike Martin said Crawford was taken into custody without incident.

Crawford was hired by the city in 1998 and worked as a patrol officer. Martin said there had been no prior discipline problems with Crawford that he was aware of.

"When he resigned from the department Wednesday, he indicated he had some personal problems that he had to deal with," Martin said.

Officers were notified of Crawford's resignation by internal memo.

"It's a sad day for law enforcement in the city," Martin said. "But we pride ourselves in our professionalism and that we will deal effectively with problems when they arise."

Martin said he understands that the public may be concerned with a former officer being charged with serious crimes, but the mistakes of one person should not reflect badly on the rest of the department.

"The public should have confidence that our department doesn't put up with or condone illegal behavior by anyone, including our own officers," Martin said. "We are proud of our department and the well-educated and professional men and women in it. We do a good job day after day to serve and protect the public (and) that is often overlooked."

Crawford was among a group of young officers hired in recent years to replace veteran officers who have retired from the department.

Richardson said Crawford didn't give much explanation for why he fled from sheriff's deputies attempting to pull him over Aug. 13 for reckless driving with his motorcycle. Another motorcyclist with him at the time, 22-year-old Jason John Serafin, fled from police in a different direction and died from injuries he received when his motorcycle crashed into a pursuing police vehicle.

Richardson, a retired Adrian police detective, said police officers need continued mentoring beyond their field training to become effective police officers.

"I think it takes about four years to be a seasoned cop," Richardson said. "I'm from the old school, but I think the younger cops need more mentoring from the older ones to learn how to deal with people and situations they'll face. It takes more than just knowing what the laws are."

Richardson said he worked with Crawford before he retired and said he didn't notice anything that would suggest Crawford was having problems on the job or in his personal life.

"It hurts to see a young man's career end like this," Richardson said.
















Crawford hearing delayed
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
September 1, 2001 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
ADRIAN -- A prosecutor referred to a signed confession when she argued Friday against lowering bond for a resigned Adrian police officer charged with criminal sexual conduct and fleeing police.

Jason Crawford, wearing a black and white striped Monroe County jail uniform, was led out of the courtroom in handcuffs after the motion was denied by Lenawee County District Judge Natalia M. Koselka.

He is to return to court Wednesday morning for a preliminary examination on criminal sexual conduct and fleeing charges that could bring a prison sentence.

He is accused of sexually assaulting a woman at her Adrian home earlier this year and with being one of two motorcyclists who fled a police traffic stop on Aug. 13. The other motorcycle rider, Jason John Serafin, 22, of Adrian, died in a head-on collision with an Adrian Township police car.

An attorney for 27-year-old Crawford asked for a reduction in his $50,000 bond because of the risks the former police officer faces in being locked in jail.

Crawford is being held in isolation for his protection at a Monroe County jail facility, attorney Robert Jameson said, adding it is a very difficult position for a police officer to be in.

"He just does not have the means to post his bond," Jameson told the court.

Although he is charged with fleeing a traffic stop, Jameson said, having been on the Adrian Police Department for three years should indicate there is little risk in releasing him on bond.

"I believe Mr. Crawford will appear at all his court hearings," Jameson said.

Assistant Lenawee County prosecutor Laura Schaedler noted her office went far enough in agreeing last week to a reduction in the original $150,000 bond amount.

"Mr. Crawford has signed a confession admitting his participation in a criminal sexual conduct offense of the first degree and second degree," Schaedler said.

He also reportedly admitted to the motorcycle chase incident.

"He did these things while he was sworn to serve and protect," Schaedler said. "He took advantage of the people he was supposed to be serving and protecting."

Crawford is almost certainly facing a conviction and sentence that will include incarceration, she argued, so Crawford may as well be serving time now that can be credited toward his sentence.

Koselka ruled she was not persuaded the bond should be reduced further than the $50,000 amount set a week ago.

A hearing scheduled for Friday afternoon was adjourned to Wednesday because a public defender appointed to represent him was unavailable due to a family emergency.

Schaedler said Crawford has admitted to sexually assaulting a woman acquaintance at her home this spring. There are no allegations he took advantage of his authority as a police officer to commit the offense, she said.

Lenawee County Sheriff Larry Richardson said Crawford confessed to him last week that he was the motorcyclist who, with Serafin, fled a sheriff's deputy on Aug. 13. The deputy attempted to stop the motorcyclists for reckless driving on South Main Street near the Adrian Mall, he said.

They sped west on U.S. 223 at more than 100 miles per hour, deputies reported, then split up on the west side of Adrian.

One motorcyclist turned back into the city on West Maumee Street. Serafin turned north on Wolf Creek Highway then sped east on Hunt Road where he collided with a stopped Adrian Township patrol car west of Tipton Highway.
















Crawford asks for trial
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
September 13, 2001 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
Former Adrian patrol officer Jason Crawford pleaded not guilty Wednesday in Lenawee County Circuit Court to the criminal sexual conduct and felony fleeing police charges that forced him to resign last month.

Crawford, 27, is free on bond while he awaits a jury trial scheduled for Nov. 27 by Judge Timothy P. Pickard. Defense attorney John Glaser asked for at least two months to prepare for trial. There are six hours of video tapes and more hours of audio tape of Crawford's interviews with Michigan State Police investigators that he has not received yet, Glaser said.

Assistant Lenawee County prosecutor Laura Schaedler said during a bond hearing Aug. 31 that Crawford had signed a confession to the sex offense involving an incident at an Adrian woman's home earlier this year.

Sheriff Larry Richardson reported Crawford confessed to him that he fled a deputy attempting to make a traffic stop on South Main Street in Adrian on Aug. 13. Two motorcyclists sped away on U.S. 223, deputies reported. One of the motorcyclists, Jason John Serafin, 22, of Adrian died in a head-on collision with an Adrian Township patrol car.
















Crawford rejects offer
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
November 2, 2001 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
Former Adrian police officer Jason Crawford rejected plea bargain offers and is headed to a jury trial later this month to decide criminal sexual conduct and fleeing police charges filed against him in August.

"We are prepared for trial in this matter, your honor," defense attorney James Daly of Adrian told the court Wednesday after stating Crawford had rejected prosecution offers to plead to reduced charges.

Crawford, 27, is scheduled for trial Nov. 27 in Lenawee County Circuit Judge Timothy P. Pickard's court in the criminal sexual conduct case. He remains free on a $50,000 bond.

After a Michigan State Police investigation, Crawford was charged with sexually assaulting an Adrian woman at her home in March. He resigned Aug. 22 from the Adrian Police Department.

He was also charged with fleeing from a Lenawee County sheriff's deputy who tried to pull him over for recklessly driving a motorcycle on Aug. 13. A second motorcyclist, 22-year-old Jason John Serafin of Adrian, died when he collided with an Adrian Township police car after Crawford and Serafin split up during the high-speed police pursuit.
















Crawford trial delayed
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
November 27, 2001 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
A sexual assault trial for former Adrian police officer Jason Crawford was rescheduled for Jan. 8 after a hearing Tuesday in Lenawee County Circuit Court where a plea bargain was again discussed.

Crawford, 27, resigned from the police department in August after he was charged with sexually assaulting an Adrian woman earlier this year.

He also faces a felony charge of fleeing and eluding police for speeding away from a Lenawee County sheriff's deputy who attempted a traffic stop of two motorcyclists on Aug. 13. The second cyclist, Jason John Serafin, 22, of Adrian died when he crashed into an Adrian Township police car during the pursuit.

Crawford rejected a plea offer from the Lenawee County prosecutor's office on Oct. 31 in the criminal sexual conduct case. A trial scheduled for Tuesday was called off after resumption of plea bargain discussions
















Ex-cop draws jail term
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
December 19, 2001 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
ADRIAN -- A former Adrian police officer will serve a maximum of one year in jail for sexually assaulting a woman and fleeing from police under a plea agreement reached Wednesday in Lenawee County Circuit Court.

Jason Crawford, 27, who resigned from the Adrian Police Department in August, admitted forcing a woman to have sex with him this spring. He also admitted fleeing from a traffic stop with another motorcyclist who subsequently was killed in a collision during the Aug. 13 high-speed chase outside Adrian.

Crawford remains free on bond while he waits for sentencing that Judge Timothy P. Pickard scheduled for Jan. 29.

Assistant Lenawee County prosecutor Douglas Hartung told the court that victims in the case agreed to the reductions to resolve the case.

The plea bargain reversed Crawford's earlier stand of insisting he was innocent in the criminal sexual conduct case and wanting a jury trial. Crawford formally rejected a plea bargain offer at an Oct. 31 hearing.

Negotiations resumed as the trial approached, however. The case was adjourned from Nov. 27 to Jan. 8.

The agreement that came out of the discussions limits Crawford's punishment to no more than one year in a county jail although the sexual assault charge to which he pleaded guilty carries up to a 10-year prison term. A fourth-degree fleeing and eluding charge to which he also pleaded guilty carries a maximum two-year prison term.

Defense attorney James Daly said a one-year jail term is within the sentencing guideline range he calculated in the case.

Crawford admitted Wednesday he did commit a sexual assault on the woman who filed a complaint with Michigan State Police in June.

"We had sex and she didn't want to," Crawford told the court Wednesday.

A signed statement given to a state police detective investigating the case also proved his guilt, prosecutors have said.

"Crawford has signed a confession admitting his participation in a criminal sexual conduct offense of the first degree and second degree," assistant Lenawee County prosecutor Laura Schaedler said at a bond hearing in September.

He had also admitted to the motorcycle chase incident.

"He did these things while he was sworn to serve and protect," Schaedler said. "He took advantage of the people he was supposed to be serving and protecting."

The sexual assault happened at an Adrian woman's home where Crawford was visiting. There was no allegation he used his position as a police officer to coerce the woman. Crawford resigned from the police force after being put on suspension while detectives investigated the allegations.

In the fleeing police case, Crawford turned himself in to the Lenawee County Sheriff's Department before he was identified as a suspect in a chase that ended with the death of his companion, 22-year-old Jason John Serafin of Adrian.

Sheriff's department reports said two motorcyclists were driving recklessly on South Main Street when a sheriff's deputy attempted a traffic stop. They sped away on U.S. 223 and split up on the west side of Adrian.

Crawford turned onto Maumee Street and escaped. Serafin drove north on Wolf Creek Highway and minutes later crashed head-on into an Adrian Township police car on Hunt Road west of Tipton Highway.
















Sheriff satisfied with plea
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
December 20, 2001 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
ADRIAN -- Lenawee County Sheriff Larry Richardson said he's satisfied with a plea arrangement reached Wednesday with a former Adrian police officer in Lenawee County Circuit Court.

Jason Crawford, 27, will serve a maximum of one year in jail after admitting in court that he sexually assaulted a woman last spring and led sheriff's deputies on a high-speed pursuit with his motorcycle in August. He is free on bond and sentencing is scheduled for Jan. 29 before Judge Timothy P. Pickard.

Richardson said Crawford acknowledged early in the sheriff's department investigation that he was one of two motorcyclists that sheriff's deputies were chasing. Crawford's behavior was unacceptable, Richardson noted, but he did step forward and cooperated when confronted about the incident.

"From day one, he took responsibility for his actions," Richardson said. "I think that he feels he has to face the consequences of his actions, and I think that he will."

The one-year jail term is substantially less than the combined maximum prison time of approximately 12 years Crawford originally faced for both charges. Victims agreed to the reductions offered in the plea agreement to resolve the case.

Crawford was hired by the Adrian Police Department in January 1998 and worked as a patrol officer. Richardson, a retired Adrian police detective, said he worked with Crawford and didn't sense that the young officer was having trouble.

Fellow officers on Crawford's shift said they were not aware of any specific problems that Crawford may have been having prior to the incidents, Richardson said.

Crawford was suspended from the police department in June while Michigan State Police investigated the sexual assault complaint against him. He resigned from the police department two days before he was served with warrants for his arrest.
















Adrian police dismissed from lawsuit
Daily Telegram, The (Adrian, MI)
March 27, 2004 
https://infoweb.newsbank.com/
ADRIAN -- The city of Adrian and four police officers were dismissed from a lawsuit over the death of a Hudson man who was punched during an argument with a man in Adrian.

There is no evidence the officers were responsible for the death of Christopher Conley several hours after a confrontation they were called to investigate on Sept. 29, 2000, ruled Lenawee County Circuit Judge Harvey A. Koselka.

The ruling leaves Thomas Bobzean as the lone defendant in a trial scheduled for June 22.

Bobzean is accused of throwing a single punch that struck Conley in the head. The 25-year-old Hudson man died as a result of a skull fracture allegedly caused by the blow, according to court documents. A lawsuit brought by Conley's family claimed Adrian police caused his death by not calling an ambulance or taking Conley to a hospital.

There is no evidence to show Conley could not have sought medical treatment on his own, argued defense attorney John Whitman of Ann Arbor at a hearing Monday. He represented former officer Jason Crawford and officers Robin Burke, John Paine and Jack Deland.

"What would Conley have done that he was restrained from doing?" Whitman asked the court.

Conley was fully conscious and talking with officers who first arrived in response to a domestic dispute complaint, he said. There is no evidence he was in police custody, he said, or that he and a friend, Jesse Williams, could not leave.

When Conley's condition began to deteriorate, an officer gave him a breath test that showed a 0.17 percent blood alcohol level, Whitman noted. The officers and Williams have all said they assumed Conley was simply intoxicated rather than suffering from a serious head injury.

Crawford drove Conley and Williams to a relative's home in Adrian where he died in his sleep.

Police have immunity from negligence claims of this type so they will not be burdened with lawsuits that interfere with their ability to perform their work, Whitman argued. They can be sued only for gross negligence, he said, and there is no evidence they acted in disregard of Conley's life and health.

Bobzean is responsible for Conley's death, Whitman argued. Showing that police could have done something after the assault to save his life does not mean they directly caused his death, he said.

Attorney Kurt Olson of Allen Park argued there is enough evidence of gross negligence to take the case to a jury.

"Once you determine there is an incapacity you have to follow the letter of the law," Olson said. Conley should have been taken into protective custody and given medical treatment, he said, as stated in an affidavit by a former Dearborn police officer and criminal justice professor named as an expert for the case.

An affidavit from Dr. Werner Spitz of Gross Pointe Shores stated, "With appropriate medical attention, Christopher Conley's chances for survival would have been excellent."

Even concluding that Conley would have been saved, Koselka ruled, there is no evidence police had a duty to take him to a hospital.






Thursday, February 1, 2001

01312001 - Commissionner Kurt Kramer - Assaulted Police Officer - Macomb County

Also See:

Commisioner Kurt Kramer charged with domestic violence [November 26, 2002]

January 2001: Kramer assaulted a police officer who was serving him a protective order.

Man to take county post despite charges
Commissioner-elect is facing 2 abuse counts
December 5, 2002
BY MARY OWEN AND NANCY
DETROIT FREE PRESS
http://www.freep.com/news/locmac/kramer5_20021205.htm

A newly elected Macomb County commissioner will face a judge on domestic violence charges days after he is sworn into office.

Kurt Kramer, 47, was charged Nov. 27 with two counts of domestic violence and released the next day on $300 bond. His pretrial hearing is scheduled for Dec. 16 in 42-2 District Court, which is temporarily located in Mt. Clemens.


His wife, Russia native Lyubov Arestova, 34, told police that her husband attacked her Nov. 26 after she refused to take off her clothes and pose for nude photographs, according to police documents.

One of his previous wives, Oxana Kramer, a Ukrainian mail-order bride, obtained a personal protection order against him almost two years ago, said Chesterfield Township Police Lt. Dave Marker. Kramer has been married four times.

While being charged with a misdemeanor doesn't prevent a commissioner from serving on the board under county rules, some of Kramer's future colleagues are wary of the bad publicity that follows such allegations.

"People have a negative enough image of politics without having this happen," said Commissioner Diana Kolakowski of Sterling Heights. "It doesn't exactly support the family values platform."

But Commissioner Mike Sessa of Harrison Township, who bailed Kramer out of jail, said people are unfairly assuming that Kramer is guilty. He noted that Kramer is the sole caregiver of his 80-year-old father. "I can't understand why this would happen to him," said Sessa, who has known Kramer for four years. "I would give him the benefit of the doubt."

Kramer of New Baltimore said he plans to attend the Dec. 12 swearing-in ceremony and take his seat Jan.1. He said his personal life will not interfere with his commission duties.

He listed his job priorities as road improvements and finding a permanent location for the 42-2 District Court, temporarily housed in the county jail. "Give me a chance to prove myself," Kramer said. "I plan to do what they elected me to do."

Kramer, an Air Force reservist, said he and Arestova were the perfect couple during his successful bid for Macomb County's 14th District, which includes Chesterfield Township, Lenox Township, New Baltimore and New Haven Village.

The Republican beat Democrat Wendy Iacobelli for the seat being vacated by commission Chairman John Hertel, who announced his resignation in May.

Arestova, who Kramer said has been learning English since she arrived in the United States, helped with mailings and neighborhood walks and attended victory parties, Kramer said. But soon after, Arestova became short-tempered, he said. Kramer said Wednesday that he hasn't seen his wife since the incident.

He said the trouble began when he asked if he could put some of her clothes, which smelled like cigarette smoke, in their enclosed porch because the smell was bothering him. Kramer said she stormed out of their bedroom wearing only a robe and went to her son's room where she changed and later threatened to tell police he had tried to rip her clothes off.

On Wednesday evening, Arestova said, "It's a very bad situation." She declined further comment, saying her English is bad and her social worker could better explain her side of the story.

Police were called to the scene by Arestova's 14-year-old son who said Kramer choked him, Marker said.

Kramer, a jet fueler at Selfridge Air National Guard Base, said he met Arestova through a friend when he was vacationing in Russia in June 2001. They communicated for a while before she came to the United States with her son. The couple lived together for about six months before marrying in January. Kramer believes the couple could still work things out.

Ex-wife Oxana Kramer sought a personal protection order against him in January 2001. But he assaulted a police officer who went to Kramer's house to serve the papers, according to police reports. Kramer pleaded guilty to the assault and battery charge. He served one year of probation to the misdemeanor charge.

The commission seat is Kramer's first elected post. He served briefly on the Oakland County Board of Commissioners in the early 1990s, when he lived in Oak Park. He was appointed to complete a term left vacant by a commissioner who died. Kramer lost his 1994re-election bid for the seat.













Official accused of assaulting wife
Police say Macomb commissioner-elect beat her after she refused to pose for nude pictures
11/29/02
By Gene Schabath
The Detroit News
http://www.detnews.com/2002/metro/0211/29/c02-23081.htm

CHESTERFIELD TOWNSHIP -- Newly elected Macomb County Commissioner Kurt Kramer was charged with assaulting his wife, two years after allegedly attacking his first wife.

The most recent allegation comes from his wife of 10 months, Lyubov Arestova, 34, said Chesterfield Police Detective Jim Gates.

Kramer tried to tear off his Russian-born wife's clothing and attacked her in the upstairs bedroom of their home when she refused to pose nude for photographs that he wanted to put on the Internet, Gates said.

Kramer first choked the 34-year-old woman's 14-year-old son and forced him out of the house, Gates said.

Kramer, 48, was arraigned Wednesday before 42nd District Judge Paul Cassidy of New Baltimore on two counts of domestic violence. He was released under $300 bond.

Domestic violence is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days in jail.

Kramer said in an interview Thanksgiving Day that he is innocent and is confident he will be acquitted. "That is a totally ludicrous statement on my wife's part," Kramer said. "It appears to be part of a big scam. She gets married to an American citizen and then uses the domestic violence charge to fulfill whatever agenda she has. I think she wants the INS (immigration and Naturalization Service) to look favorably on her if she files the domestic abuse charge. Her status in the United States is pending. She doesn't even have a green card."

Kramer said he wanted to take the photographs of his wife because she undresses in front of her teen-age son. He claims he was attacked by his wife, but said police would not listen to his side of the story.

Kramer was elected to the county board Nov. 5 to represent District 14, which includes Chesterfield, Lenox Township and New Baltimore. The part time position pays $33,000 a year.

He said he lost his job at Kmart last year and now works part-time as a fuel specialist at Selfridge Air National Guard Base where he is also in the Air Force reserves.

He previously was arrested Nov. 17, 2000, for assaulting his first wife, also a Russian-born woman, Oxana Savina, Gates said.
She was in her late 30s, Gates said.

"This one is the same as the first one," Gates said. "Almost identical."

His first wife divorced Kramer in January 2001. He married his new wife in January of this year. Kramer said he met her in Russia while on duty as a reservist.

The first domestic abuse charge was dropped when Kramer pleaded guilty to resisting arrest. He was placed on probation for one year and fined $200. Gates said the arresting officer was attacked when he went to Kramer's house to serve him a personal protection order the first wife had obtained against him after he attacked her.

Kramer's new wife gave police two rolls of film she had shot of injuries suffered in previous attacks, Gates said.

Macomb County Board Chairman John Hertel said the county legal staff is investigating whether Kramer can be expelled from office if convicted.

"It's a sad and disturbing situation," Hertel said. Kramer replaces Hertel as the commissioner from District 14. Hertel did not run for re-election.

Kramer said he plans to be at swearing-in ceremonies for county commissioners on Dec. 12.












Recently Elected Official in Michigan Denies Domestic Violence Charge
From The Associated Press, 11/29/02
http://ap.tbo.com/ap/breaking/MGAO0W3X39D.html

CHESTERFIELD TOWNSHIP, Mich. - A recently elected county commissioner is facing domestic violence charges for allegedly shoving and striking his wife.

Kurt Kramer, 47, expected to take office in January, was arrested Tuesday and spent a night in jail before being released on a $300 bond. His next court hearing was scheduled for Dec. 16, four days after he is to be sworn in to the Macomb County Board of Commissioners.

According to police, Kramer's wife, Lyubov Arestova, said he pushed and hurt her after she allegedly refused to pose for nude photographs. He also is accused of choking a 14-year-old relative in the melee.

Kramer told the Associated Press on Thursday, "No, I didn't hit her, and no, I didn't strike her." He also denied asking her to pose nude.

Kramer has a previous assault and battery conviction for slamming a door on a police officer's arm and leg as the officer tried to serve Kramer with a personal protection order from his former wife, who alleged that he assaulted her.