04042013 - Officer Ryan McClimans - Grand Rapids PD

GR cop pleads guilty, plans to retire
Lt. Ryan McClimans pleads guilty in domestic case
Updated: Friday, 26 Apr 2013, 10:39 PM EDT
Published : Friday, 26 Apr 2013, 10:39 PM EDT
http://www.woodtv.com/dpp/news/local/ottawa_county/gr-cop-pleads-guilty-plans-to-retire

HOLLAND, Mich. (WOOD) - A Grand Rapids police lieutenant has entered a plea in a case involving domestic violence.

On April 4, police said Lt. Ryan McClimans, 43, was involved in a domestic dispute in Holland while he was off duty.

Holland police began investigating the incident, and McClimans turned himself in on April 11 after the Ottawa County Prosecutor’s Office issued a misdemeanor warrant against him.

According to the Grand Rapids Police Department, McClimans was arraigned, released on a personal recognizance bond and put on administrative leave from GRPD.

On Friday, McClimans’ attorney told 24 Hour News 8 that his client had entered a guilty plea on Thursday under the Michigan Spousal Abuse Act, which allows first-time offenders to be put on probation where a judge can include conditions like mandatory counseling or a jail time of up to 12 months.

If McClimans successfully completes his probation, his record will be sealed and the guilty plea will not show on his record unless he re-offends.

McClimans’ attorney also said his client told the Ottawa County Prosecutor’s Office that he intended to retire from his position with GRPD.

Sentencing for McClimans is scheduled for May 28.













Grand Rapids police lieutenant pleads guilty to domestic violence

The Grand Rapids Press
John Tunison
April 26, 2013 at 4:40 PM
Updated April 26, 2013 at 4:42 PM

GRAND RAPIDS, MI -- A Grand Rapids police lieutenant has pleaded guilty to domestic violence involving a Holland woman.

Lt. Ryan McClimans, 43, is expected to be sentenced May 28 in Holland District Court on the misdemeanor. He pleaded guilty on Thursday, April 25, court records show.

McClimans is an 18-year veteran with the Grand Rapids Police Department,

He is accused of pushing the Holland woman he was dating, causing her to hit her head on a tool box.

The incident happened April 4.

McClimans, who filed for divorce in February to end a 10-year marriage, has been on paid leave with Grand Rapids police since April 5.

His status with the department today was not immediately known.

McClimans is assigned to the police Special Response Team.














Grand Rapids police lieutenant charged with domestic violence made a death threat, woman alleges
By Heidi Fenton
The Grand Rapids Press
April 12, 2013 at 7:36 PM
Updated April 12, 2013 at 7:57 PM
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2013/04/grand_rapids_police_lieutenant_1.html

OTTAWA COUNTY, MI -- A Holland woman claims she was physically abused by the Grand Rapids police lieutenant she was dating.

But the officer's attorney on Friday, April 12, described the case -- involving a domestic violence charge -- as a "he said, she said," event.

"I'm not sure a crime occurred," said Terry Tobias, the attorney for Lt. Ryan McClimans, an 18-year veteran officer.

"It's two people saying different things about what happened," he said.

McClimans, 43, was charged with the domestic violence misdemeanor in Holland District Court and has been on paid administrative leave with the Grand Rapids Police Department since April 5.

The alleged victim, Sarah Ritsema, 32, detailed her claims against McClimans in a personal protection order filed April 5, the day after she was allegedly abused.

McClimans allegedly told her “I’m going to kill you” following a haircut she gave him, she wrote in a statement. The episode ended with an argument and her pushed to the ground, court records allege.

In a nine-page affidavit filed for the protection order, Ritsema said: “I want nothing more than for him to stay as far away as possible from me and my children.” Her account is riddled with instances of verbal and mental abuse in addition to property damage that includes allegations of kicking in doors and punching holes in walls.

Ottawa County Circuit Court Judge Edward Post approved the protection order without testimony or a chance for McClimans to respond to the allegations. It is standard practice for that to occur and the subject of the order can later request an opportunity to contest the claims.

On the morning of April 4, Ritsema said McClimans was upset after a haircut she gave him did not turn out as he liked. McClimans looked in the mirror, grew angry and allegedly began to scream, saying “I made him look bad on purpose,” Ritsema wrote.

The exchange escalated as Ritsema allegedly told McClimans to move out because she had taken enough. He tried to initiate emotional contact, she wrote, and she said “no,” pushing him away.

Ritsema alleged McClimans then pushed her down on a bed where he had placed tools while he removed a TV from a wall. The bed slid and hit the wall. Ritsema said she fell to the ground and she hit her head on a toolbox.

Moments later, in the bathroom, McClimans tried to grab a necklace from her neck and then “screamed in my face … ‘I’m going to kill you,'" Ritsema wrote.

Tobias said his McClimans offers a different account.

"There was definitely arguing by the parties that went back and forth," Tobias said. "(McClimans) tried to calm the argument down by giving her a hug. She gave him a push and they both tumbled backwards, falling on the bed.

"He had no intent to ever harm her. I think it's one of those things where two people see things differently," he said.

After the incident, Ritsema went to work and did not report the trouble to police until later in the day, he said.

Tobias said McClimans has an exemplary record with the Grand Rapids police force and he hopes it stays unblemished.

"He's pretty well decorated and seems to have done some pretty heroic things," he said.

In the lengthy affidavit, Ritsema told how her year-and-a-half long dating relationship with McClimans was riddled with verbal abuse and anger. She recounts allegations but offers no time frame for the arguments.

She wrote of other incidents, one about six months ago in which McClimans drove her home from Boatwerks Restaurant in Holland in his police cruiser, then became angry with texts on her phone.

He said the couple was breaking up that night, Ritsema wrote, but “he was getting one more round out of me,” then allegedly tried to force her to engage in sexual contact.

Records show McClimans filed for divorce from his wife in February 2013, citing a breakdown in the 10-year marriage.

McClimans was promoted to lieutenant in March 2012. He played an integral role in the July 2011 standoff with Rodrick Dantzler, who killed seven people in Grand Rapids before taking his own life.

Grand Rapids police Chief Kevin Belk said McClimans will remain on leave pending the outcome of an internal investigation and a determination of what departmental rule violations happened, if any.

                












 Grand Rapids officer charged with domestic violence, on leave
4:30 PM, Apr 12, 2013
http://www.wzzm13.com/news/article/252335/14/Grand-Rapids-officer-charged-with-domestic-violence-on-leave

GRAND RAPIDS (WZZM) - A Grand Rapids Police lieutenant has been placed on administrative leave after an alleged domestic violence incident in Holland.

Lieutenant Ryan McClimans was placed on leave pending the outcome of the investigation of the complaint. Based on investigations by the Holland Police Department, the Ottawa County Prosecutor issued a misdemeanor warrant charging McClimans with Domestic Violence. According to Grand Rapids Police, McClimans turned himself in to Holland Police Thursday, was arraigned, and released on bond.

Lt. McClimans is part of the Grand Rapids Special Response Team.



           









Grand Rapids police lieutenant on leave after domestic violence charge
By John Tunison
The Grand Rapids Press
April 12, 2013 at 11:38 AM
Updated April 12, 2013 at 7:38 PM
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2013/04/grand_rapids_police_lieutenant.html

UPDATE: Grand Rapids police lieutenant charged with domestic violence made a death threat, woman alleges

GRAND RAPIDS, MI -- An 18-year Grand Rapids police lieutenant is on administrative leave after he was charged with domestic violence in Ottawa County.

Lt. Ryan McClimans, 43, was arraigned April 11 in Holland District Court on the charge, a misdemeanor. An April 25 pretrial is scheduled in the case.

McClimans was placed on paid leave April 5, a day after the alleged domestic violence incident happened in Holland.

McClimans is assigned to the police Special Response Team. After he was arraigned, he was released on a personal recognizance bond.

He was promoted to lieutenant in March 2012.

McClimans played an integral role in the July 2011 standoff with Rodrick Dantzler, who killed seven people before entering a home on Rickman Ave. NE and taking hostages.

He ended up taking his own life after a four-hour standoff.

               











GR Lt charged in domestic violence case

43-year-old Ryan McClimans
Updated: Friday, 12 Apr 2013, 11:32 AM EDT
Published : Friday, 12 Apr 2013, 10:54 AM EDT
http://www.woodtv.com/dpp/news/ottawa_county/gr-lt-charged-in-domestic-violence-case

HOLLAND, Mich. (WOOD) - A Grand Rapids police lieutenant was placed on administrative leave as an investigation continues regarding his alleged off-duty involvement in a domestic violence case.

The incident is alleged to have happened in Holland on April 4, and the Holland Police Department began working on the case.

The Ottawa County Prosecutor's Office then issued a misdemeanor warrant against Lt. Ryan McClimans.

The 43-year-old turned himself into the Holland Police Department on April 11 and was arraigned afterward.

He was then released on a personal recognizance bond, according to a news release from the Grand Rapids Police Department.

McClimans began his career with GRPD in 1994 and was assigned the Special Response Team.










Grand Rapids Officer Being Investigated
April 12, 2013
by Carl Gustin
Assignment Editor
http://fox17online.com/2013/04/12/grand-rapids-officer-being-investigated/#axzz2QTu7ztxu

GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. — A Grand Rapids police lieutenant has been placed on leave while he is being investigated.

Lt. Ryan McClimans, 43, was placed on administrative leave April 5 while the department looks into an April 4 domestic violence allegation in Holland. The Ottawa County Prosecutor’s Office issued a warrant for misdemeanor domestic violence for McClimans, who surrendered Thursday and was arraigned in 58th District Court.

He was released on personal recognizance.

McClimans has been an officer with the Grand Rapids Police Department since 1994.

05282011 - [Officer] Clarence Ratliff dies in prison - Murdered Judge Carol Irons - Grand Rapids

03161975 - Grand Rapids PD Officer Clarence Ratliff - Assault of First Wife 

03161975 - Grand Rapids PD Officer Clarence Ratliff - Suspension From Duty - Assault Of First Wife 

10191988 - Grand Rapids PD Officer Clarence Ratliff - Murdered his estranged wife Judge Carol Irons

10191988 - Grand Rapids PD Officer Clarence Ratliff - Shot At Officer Daniel Ostopowski, After Ratliff Murdered Estranged Wife/Judge Carol Irons

10191988 - Grand Rapids PD Officer Clarence Ratliff - Shot At Officer John Den Boer, After Ratliff Murdered Estranged Wife/Judge Carol Irons

06121989 - [Grand Rapids PD Officer] Clarence Ratliff - Sentenced - Murder Of Ex-Wife Judge Carol Irons

10241991 - [Grand Rapids PD Officer] Clarence Ratliff  - Appeal - Conviction Affirmed

05092011 - [Grand Rapids PD Officer] Clarence Ratliff - Judge Carol Irons' Murderer Requests To Be Freed From Prison

05282011 - [Grand Rapids PD Officer] Clarence Ratliff dies in prison - Murdered Judge Carol Irons 

Officer Clarence Ratliff murdered his ex-wife, Judge Carol Irons [October 18, 1988]:

Clarence Ratliff's family was asking he be freed

Wood TV News

June 01, 2011

http://www.woodtv.com/dpp/news/local/grand_rapids/Clarence-Ratliff-dies
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (WOOD) - About a month after his family filed to have him released from prison because he was dying of cancer, a former Grand Rapids police officer who shot his wife in 1988 in her courthouse chambers died in a federal prison hospice unit, a prison officer told 24 Hour News 8 on Wednesday.

Clarence Ratliff, 75, died Saturday morning at the unit inside the Butner Federal Correctional Complex in Butner, N.C., the officer said.

More than 22 years earlier, on Oct. 18, 1988, Ratliff entered the courthouse chambers of his wife -- Judge Carol Irons -- and shot her. Irons died.

Ratliff's family was asking that the 75-year-old be released from prison so he could spend his last days with them in his former home along the Muskegon River.

"The family's contention is, enough is enough," lawyer John Smietanka told 24 Hour News 8 last month. "He needs to die at home."

Smietanka said at the time that Ratliff was bed-ridden, could not speak and would not offend again.

But ultimately, the 75-year-old served the entire sentence handed down June 12, 1989, by then-Judge Dennis Kolenda: Life.

"You struck close to a mortal blow to the peace, dignity and safety of this community," Kolenda said during sentencing. "Then, when this community in the person of police officers came to the rescue of the person you had mortally wounded, you attempted to kill them. I can imagine no worse crime."

Ratliff and Irons were going through a divorce. The former officer's defense was that he was too drunk to have known what he was doing, according to archived 24 Hour News 8 reports. Ratliff was convicted of manslaughter for killing his wife and assault with intent to murder for shooting at the fellow officers who responded.

That prompted protests, with one speaker expressing outrage that "the murder of a woman is considered less serious than shooting at and missing two men."

The assault charges eventually led to the life sentence.

One of Irons' friends, lawyer Diann Landers, told 24 Hour News 8 that she believes this "is what life in prison means."

Another friend, Judge Sara Smolenski, said while she too opposed Ratliff's release, she does not find any joy or peace in his death.

"The whole experience has been just horrendous for her family, for their family," she said. "It's really never over because it's something you live with your whole life."

Smietanka called Ratliff's death the end to a very sad story.

05092011 - [Officer] Clarence Ratliff - Judge Carol Irons' Murderer Requests To Be Freed From Prison - Grand Rapids

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "IN MEMORY OF JUDGE CAROL IRONS [KENT COUNTY]":

Shame on Michigan Parole Board for considering the "Rat's" release on "humanitarian" grounds. I say let him out feet first with toe tag on, with priority delivery to the hot afterlife he deserves. He ruined my mothers life the day he shot Judge Irons, she'll never be the same after watching Carol bleed to death in her arms. I'll never forget the day my Mother came home covered in blood, and hasn't been the same since.

Shame on G.R. Press for printing an article quasi supporting his release; and on Mother's Day no less! My Mom really had a wonderful day after picking up the paper from her front porch and seeing the "Rat" on the front page.

Judge Carol Irons

I just received the following email today, regarding the possibility that Ratliff may be released from prison

Former Grand Rapids Police Officer, Clarence Ratliff [murdered Judge Carol Irons]

Judge Carol Irons, gunned down and killed by her ex-husband, Officer Ratliff [October 19, 1988].

On October 19, 1988, Officer Ratliff walked into the Grand Rapids Courthouse...and into his ex-wife's [Judge Carol Irons] chambers

Using his 9mm duty weapon, Officer Ratliff shot several rounds off at Judge Carol Irons...at least one of those rounds fired by Ratliff, hit Judge Carol Irons in her neck.

Judge Carol Irons died in her chambers, of a gunshot wound to the neck.

And for some reason, Ratliff, who is dying of cancer, believes he deserves to die in a more dignified place, than behind bars?

Should Clarence Ratliff be allowed out of prison more than 22 years after he killed Judge Carol Irons?
The Grand Rapids Press
May 10, 2011

http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2011/05/from_the_comments_should_clare.html

The appeal on behalf of Cancer-stricken former Grand Rapids Police Officer Clarence Ratliff to be allowed to die outside prison has readers commenting online.

So far, the majority of comments have been opposed to the idea of freeing a man who killed his estranged wife -- Grand Rapids District Court Judge Carol Irons -- and then fired at fellow police officers as he tried to escape the former court house.

But there is a group who point out that although he was given a life sentence for shooting at police, he was convicted of manslaughter in Irons' killing and given a sentence of 17 years.

The question is whether Ratliff, now a 75 year-old man who spent the last 22 years behind bars should be allowed to die with his family.

Many of the readers posted variations on the sentiments of Keynote:
"Ratliff took an oath to "serve and protect," and then I assume he thought he was above the law. According to testimonies, it wasn't a spur of the moment thing, he had forethought. He is not the only prisoner who has become terminally ill in prison. Do you think that other prisoners are afforded release just because they're sick. "NO!" He may be remorseful now and even repentant, but that does not bring back the life of this woman. When he pulled that trigger, he himself made the choice of where he wanted to spend the rest of his life...sick or not."

Bluemoontwo frames the issue in stark terms:
"Still remember this tragic day, so many years later! What should he get respect and dignity for killing his wife? He sure didn't give that to her, he shot her with his hatred! So he is dying, he chose to do this terrible crime, let him rot in jail!"

But a few people believe that Ratliff is entitled to leave prison , including Ms. Rat:"Clarence Ratliff was not convicted of murder, he was convicted of manslaughter. He has served 24 years in prison. He is not some backwoods murderer. He is a retired marine corp veteran, who served in Vietnam. He served on the Grand Rapids bomb squad for many years. He has served, protected, and saved many lives. I'm sure most of you writing these comments were not even born when this crime occurred. He has done more good in his life than you could even imagine. he does deserve to be treated like a human being. To the comments of him not looking sick in the photo... no kidding that picture is 25 years old.

HE HAS SERVED HIS TIME! HE IS NOT A THREAT TO ANYONE! HE DESERVES TO BE PAROLED!"
DeRadMan says there should be no special treatment for Ratliff, one way or the other:
"Seems to me that he was convicted of manslaughter and not 1st degree murder. He should be treated like others who were convicted of the same offense. I suspect parole is the norm by 22 years."

E-mail Barton Deiters: bdeiters@grpress.com and follow him on Twitter at twitter.com/GRPBarton

Murderer-former cop asks to die free

Clarence Ratliff dying of cancer

WoodTV8
May 09, 2011

http://www.woodtv.com/dpp/news/local/grand_rapids/Murderer-former-cop-asks-to-die-free

GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (WOOD) - Twenty-two years after a Grand Rapids police officer shot and killed his wife, District Judge Carol Irons, he is dying of cancer.

And, now, Clarence Ratliff's family is asking the state to release him from prison, so he can spend his last few days in his former home on the Muskegon River, with family.

"If he gets through this year, it will be a miracle," said the family's attorney, former U.S. Attorney John Smietanka.

Ratliff, a 21-year veteran of the police department, was drunk on Oct. 18, 1988, when he burst into the chambers of his estranged wife at the old Hall of Justice and shot her with his 9 mm handgun. They were going through a divorce. She stumbled out of her chambers, clutching her neck, and later died.

He got up to 15 years for the death, after being convicted of manslaughter, but life in prison for shooting at the officers who
responded. One of the officers was struck by shrapnel.

"He's sorry about what he did to his ex-wife, Judge Irons, and he will live with that -- he has lived with that for all these years," Smietanka said.

On Thursday, Smietanka asked the state for a medical commutation, which must be recommended by the Parole Board and approved by the governor.

"The family's contention is enough is enough; he needs to die at home," Smietanka said.

Ratliff, now 75, is in a federal prison hospital in North Carolina after doctors diagnosed him with cancer near his spine, which has spread to his lungs.

"Certainly, he is not going to offend again," Smietanka said. "He's in bed. He's bed-ridden, in a wheelchair. He can't speak. Today, he's got pneumonia. It's getting very close to the end."

Ratliff is getting support from more than just his family. Then-Kent Circuit Judge Dennis Kolenda, who sentenced him, wrote the
state two years ago, recommending it consider him for release.

John Den Boer, one of the Grand Rapids officers who exchanged gunfire with him, also has written to the state, asking for "compassion and mercy."

"It has been my understanding for a number of years that Clarence Ratliff has shown genuine remorse for what he did," Den Boer wrote. "I personally no longer hold any feeling of resentment for his actions, and I am convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that Clarence Ratliff is not a threat to me, to anyone else involved in the original incident, or to the public as a whole.

"It would be my request that Clarence Ratliff be given parole as soon as possible, to be with his family as he approaches death."

And, Smietanka said, former police Capt. Daniel Ostopowicz, the officer injured by shrapnel, has said he wouldn't oppose the release.

Smietanka said the commutation also would save taxpayers the expense of medical care. Ratliff would move in with his daughter, who lives on the Muskegon River, in West Michigan.

"His family will take over the burden, which is right now, on the state of Michigan and the federal government," he said.

Department of Corrections spokesman John Cordell said the parole board already was considering his release and is waiting for medical and psychological reports from federal prison before taking the next step. They expect those reports within days. He said the state only occasionally releases inmates based on medical reasons.

The state wouldn't release him without a public hearing, Cordell said.

Former friends of Irons, including 63rd District Judge Sara Smolenski, say they oppose the release.

"Mercy is something that wasn't provided to Carol when he shot her, and mercy wasn't provided to the police officers that he shot at when trying to escape when they were called," attorney Diann Landers said.

Landers keeps a photograph in her office of her and Irons the night her friend was elected Kent County's first female judge. They were not only friends, but Landers was her attorney in the judge's pending divorce case against Ratliff.

"He should do exactly what he was sentenced to do, live out his life in prison," she said. "If that means dying there, that's what it means."

Grand Rapids ex-cop who killed wife, and now is dying, gets support for release from prison

The Grand Rapids Press
May 09, 2011

http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2011/05/grand_rapids_ex-cop_who_killed.html

Should he die behind bars? The husband, Officer Clarence Ratliff, 53 at the time (above), 

now is 75 and has terminal cancer.

Press File Photos. Should her killer be let out of prison? Judge Carol Irons was slain 

in her chambers by her estranged husband in 1988.

GRAND RAPIDS — More than 22 years have passed since city police Officer Clarence Ratliff went into the downtown office of his estranged wife, District Judge Carol Irons, pulled out a 9mm pistol and shot her to death.

Now, he is facing his mortality in a federal prison hospital, where he is dying from cancer.

In a race against time, supporters of Ratliff seek to move the state Parole Board along to release him on humanitarian grounds — a request that may end up needing support from Gov. Rick Snyder, according to attorney John Smietanka, a former federal prosecutor who is working with the supporters.

“He deserves a little dignity at the end of his life, a little peace,” said Steven Ratliff, a son from a previous marriage who lives in Alaska and has kept in contact with his father.

But for some of those close to Irons, the effort opens up old wounds.

After gunning down Irons on Oct. 19, 1988, Ratliff briefly exchanged gunfire with fellow officers in a hallway of the Hall of Justice before surrendering.

Ratliff ended up with a life sentence after he was convicted of manslaughter, shooting at police and illegal use of a gun. His action is often cited as one of the most infamous public crimes in the city’s history.

The hard-drinking cop who served on the major case team, motorcycle patrol and bomb squad now is 75 and has served about as much time in prison — in the federal system for safety reasons, because he is a former cop — as he did on the force. The man called “Rat” by friends could die at any time, his son said.

The younger Ratliff, 48, said the cancer was discovered on his father’s spine and then his lungs months ago. He has lost his voice, and even sitting in a wheelchair causes him pain.

A movement has begun to have him released so he does not have to die behind bars.

Norb Tuma, a retired manufacturer, has known Ratliff since the two served in the Marine reserves in the 1970s. He said that aside from his crime, Ratliff served his community as a soldier and policeman.

“Hell, he’s bedridden,” said the 67-year-old Tuma. “This guy is no risk to anyone.”
But letting him out finds no favor with some who remember Kent County’s first female jurist.

”When I’m outside enjoying a sunny day, one of the things that gives me a modicum of pleasure is knowing (Ratliff) is in prison and can’t enjoy these things,” said Diann Landers, who was Irons’ lawyer, campaign manager and close friend.

“There are a lot of people who do terrible things who go to prison, get sick and die,” said Landers, who now specializes in family law.

Ratliff first became eligible for parole in 2000 and has periodic reviews since then.

Former judge Dennis Kolenda is now in private practice, but he was a fresh face on the Kent County Circuit bench when he sentenced Ratliff.

Kolenda, who still may ability to veto a parole for any prisoner he sentenced, said he would not oppose release in Ratliff’s case.

“I wanted him to serve every day of the 17-year sentence he received for killing Carol Irons,” Kolenda said.

The current parole review began in February, and the state board is getting additional information from the federal prison in North Carolina, according to the Michigan Department of Corrections.

The board will be making a decision, but no time frame has been indicated.

Kent County District Judge Sara Smolenski, who claims Irons as both a close friend and a mentor, said she is still pained by the memory of the shooting.

Smolenski said a month before, while they dined at the Cottage Bar, Irons off-handedly said that if she was ever found dead, a warrant should be issued for Ratliff.

The two were separated and in the process of getting a divorce after a tumultuous marriage.

Ratliff was angry and had been drinking at West Side bars before he walked into the courthouse and shot his wife. In the days after, it was reported that Ratliff had sent Irons death threats.

Smolenski said she finds it hard to believe Ratliff deserves to be released. He confronted Irons in her chambers and shot her in the neck. She only had time to call police before dying.

“I think about how she never got the chance to be with her family when she died,” Smolenski said. “If we let him out, who is that for?”

Smolenski said she talked with Irons’ family for years after the trial, and they said Ratliff showed them no remorse. Irons’ mother, Virginia, died in 1992; her father, James, died in 2007; and her brother, Peter, died at 62 in 2008, according to the Arizona Secretary of State.

Ratliff is survived by three children and more than 10 grandchildren, some of whom visited him in prison within the last few weeks, according to Steven Ratliff.

Three supporters of Ratliff asserted the Parole Board is essentially sentencing him to die in prison. Former Wyoming Officer Michael Flynn, who retired and living in Texas and former Grand Rapids Officer George Pepper, now 73 and living up north, said it was not the intent of the judge or jury to deny such a release.

“It’s the human thing to do,” said John Robinson, a friend and motorcycle patrol partner, now retired. “There are so many victims in this: Carol Irons, her family and friends and the friends and family of (Ratliff).”

Ratliff’s son said release is just the moral thing to do.

”He made a terrible mistake a long time ago,” Steven Ratliff said.

 “But all the people who rush to oppose his release forget all the good he did.”